Alternativas para superar el hacinamiento carcelario en Colombia con enfoque en derechos humanos - Núm. 13, Junio 2015 - Criterio Jurídico Garantista - Libros y Revistas - VLEX 676925869

Alternativas para superar el hacinamiento carcelario en Colombia con enfoque en derechos humanos

AutorFernando Gómez Forero
Páginas176-189
176
Alternativas para superar el hacinamiento carcelario
en Colombia con enfoque en derechos humanos*1
Alternatives to overcome overcrowded prisons in Colombia
with a focus on Human Rights
!∀#∃%∃&∋()∗+∀,(!∋#∀#∋(
./.−0−12∋3+%4567∋+
89:;
95(>#∀?∀∃3∀(%#3≅7Α5∋(?∋Β#∀(5%(?43Α%74∗∃(%73Α%5(&∀(5%?(7Χ#7∀∆
5∀?Ε(?∀(∋7Α>%(∀?>∀7≅.47%+∀∃3∀(&∀( 5∋(#∀5%74∋∃%&∋(7∋∃(∀5( 2%∆
74∃%+4∀∃3∋(Φ(5%?(>∋?4Β5∀?(%53∀#∃%34Γ%?(>%#%(?Α(?Α>∀#%74∗∃6(
95(∋ΒΗ∀34Γ∋(∀?(2%7∀#(Α∃(%∃Χ54?4?(7#≅347∋(?∋Β#∀(∀5(Γ∀#&%&∀#∋(
∃4Γ∀5(&∀(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(∀∃(ΙΑ∀(?∀(∀∃7Α∀∃3#%∃(%2∋#%(5∋?(7∀∃∆
3#∋?(>∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋?Ε(Φ(5%(#∀5%74∗∃(ΙΑ∀(∀ϑ4?3∀(7∋∃(5%(>#∋3∀7∆
74∗∃(&∀(5∋?(&∀#∀72∋?(2Α+%∃∋?(>∋#(>%#3∀(&∀5(9?3%&∋Ε(7∋+∋(
Α∃( 4+>∀#%34Γ∋( ΙΑ∀( #∀ΙΑ4∀#∀( &∀( ?Α( >5∀∃∋( 7Α+>54+4∀∃3∋6(
9?3%(>#∋Β5∀+Χ347%(∀?(Α∃%(?43Α%74∗∃(>∀#+%∃∀∃3∀Ε(#∀7Α##∀∃∆
3∀(Φ( 7∋∃( 3∀∃&∀∃74%( %( >#∋.Α∃&4,%#?∀Ε( 5∋(ΙΑ∀(2%( ∋7%?4∋∃%∆
&∋(Α∃%(7#4?4?( ∀∃(+%3∀#4%(&∀5(&∀#∀72∋( 4∃3∀#∃%74∋∃%5(&∀( 5∋?(
&∀#∀72∋?(2Α+%∃∋?Ε( ΙΑ∀(2%( ?Α>Α∀?3∋( ∃∀7∀?%#4%+∀∃3∀(Α∃%(
#∀?>∋∃?%Β454&%&(&∀5(9?3%&∋Ε(>#∋&Α73∋(?4∃( &Α&%(&∀5(∀?3%&∋(
&∀(7∋?%?(4∃7∋∃?343Α74∋∃%5(ΙΑ∀(.Α∀(∀?3%Β5∀74&∋(>∋#(5%(Κ∋#3∀(
Κ∋∃?343Α74∋∃%5(%(3#%ΓΛ?(&∀(5%(?∀∃3∀∃74%(Μ∆ΝΟΠ(&∀(ΝΘΘΡ6(Σ%?(
7∋∃75Α?4∋∃∀?(#∀.5∀Η%∃(∀∃(?Α(7∋∃ΗΑ∃3∋(∀5(%53∋(∃4Γ∀5(&∀(4∃∀.4∆
74∀∃74%(7∋∃(5%(ΙΑ∀(?∀(2%(%73Α%&∋(>∋#(>%#3∀(&∀5(∀Η∀7Α34Γ∋(Φ(∀5(
5∀/4?5%34Γ∋(∀∃(5%(?∋5Α74∗∃(&∀(5%(7#4?4?(&∀(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(7%#∆
7∀5%#4∋(Φ(5%(∃∀7∀?4&%&(&∀( ∀+>#∀∃&∀#(%774∋∃∀?(%.4#+%34Γ%?Ε(
54Β#∀?(&∀5(&4?7Α#?∋(>#∋>∋?434Γ∋Ε(ΙΑ∀(∃∋(2%7∀(∋3#%(7∋?%( ΙΑ∀(
?4+>54.47%#(∀5(>#∋Β5∀+%(>∀#∋(∃∋(?∋5Α74∋∃%#5∋6
ΤΥΣΥς8Υ:(ΚΣΥΩ9:Ξ(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋( 7%#7∀5%#4∋Ε( &∀#∀72∋(
4∃3∀#∃%74∋∃%5(&∀(5∋?( &∀#∀72∋?(2Α+%∃∋?Ε(>∋5≅347%(7#4+4∃%5Ε(
>∋5≅347%(7%#7∀5%#4%Ε(>#4Γ%74∗∃(&∀(5%(54Β∀#3%&6
Criterio Jurídico Garantista. (Jul.-Dic. de 2015). Vol. 8, n.o 13, 176-189.
issn
: 2145-3381. Bogotá: Universidad Autónoma de Colombia.
!∀72%(&∀(#∀7∀>74∗∃Ξ(−ΨΝΟΖΝΨΖ−Θ((
!∀72%(&∀(∀Γ%5Α%74∗∃Ξ(−ΨΝΟΖΝΝΖΝ[((
!∀72%(&∀(%>#∋Β%74∗∃Ξ(−ΨΝΟΖΝΝΖ−Ο((
:;
Μ24?(%#3475∀Ε( %Β∋Α3(32∀(7Α##∀∃3( ?43Α%34∋∃(∋. (>#4?∋∃?Ε(?>∀∆
74.47%55Φ(#∀5%3∀&(3∋(>#4?∋∃( ∋Γ∀#7#∋]&4∃/(%∃&(%53∀# ∃%34Γ∀?(
3∋(∋Γ∀#7∋+∀(32∀+Ε(%#∀(>%#3(∋. ( 32∀(/∋%5(3∋(+%⊥∀(%(7#4347%5(
%∃%5Φ?4?(∋. ( 32∀(3#Α∀(5∀Γ∀5( ∋. (∋Γ∀#7#∋]&4∃/(4∃( ]2472(%#∀(
∃∋](7∀∃3∀#?(>#4?∋∃?(%∃&(32∀(#∀5%34∋∃?24>(]432(32∀(>#∋3∀7∆
34∋∃(∋. (_Α+%∃(84/23?(ΒΦ( 32∀(:3%3∀(%?(%∃(4+>∀#%34Γ∀(32%3(
#∀ΙΑ4#∀?(.Α55(7∋+>54%∃7∀Ε( 324?( 4?( %( >∀#+%∃∀∃3Ε( #∀7Α##∀∃3(
%∃&(3∀∃&(3∋(&∀∀>∀∃(?43Α%34∋∃Ε(]2472(2%?(7%Α?∀&(%(7#4?4?( 4∃(
32∀(∃3∀#∃%34∋∃%5(Σ%](∋. (_Α+%∃(84/23?(α_8βΕ(]2472(2%?(
∃∀7∀??%#45Φ(+∀%∃3(%(?3%3∀(54%Β4543Φ(4∃(324?(?43Α%34∋∃Ε(%?(%(#∀∆
?Α53(]432∋Α3(ΙΑ∀?34∋∃(∋.(χ;∃7∋∃?343Α34∋∃%5(Μ24∃/?((4∃(32∀(
:3%3∀δ( ∀?3%Β54?2∀&(ΒΦ( 32∀( Κ∋∃?343Α34∋∃%5( Κ∋Α#3( 32#∋Α/2(
32∀(.4∃%5(&∀?434∋∃(Μ∆ΝΟΠ(∋. (ΝΘΘΡ6(Μ2∀(75∋?Α#∀?(%?(%(]2∋5∀(
#∀.5∀73(∋. (32∀(24/2(5∀Γ∀5(∋. (4∃∀..474∀∃7Φ(]432(]2472(%734∋∃(
2%?(Β∀∀∃(3%⊥∀∃(ΒΦ(32∀(9ϑ∀7Α34Γ∀(%∃&(5∀/4?5%34Γ∀(Β#%∃72∀?(
4∃(32∀(?∋5Α34∋∃(∋. ( 32∀(∋Γ∀#7#∋]&4∃/(7#4?4?(4∃(>#4?∋∃?(%∃&(
32∀(∃∀∀&( 3∋( Α∃&∀#3%⊥∀(>Α#>∋?∀.Α5(%??∀#34Γ∀( ?>∀∀72( %..4#∆
+%34Γ∀(%734∋∃Ε(]2472(&∋∀?(∃∋324∃/(3∋(?4+>54.Φ(32∀(>#∋Β5∀+(
ΒΑ3(∃∋3(4∃(?∋5Γ4∃/(436(
ε9∴φγ8η:Ξ( >#4?∋∃( ∋Γ∀#7#∋]&4∃/Ε( ∃3∀#∃%34∋∃%5( _Α∆
+%∃(84/23?(5%]Ε(7#4+4∃%5(>∋547ΦΕ(>#4?∋∃(>∋547ΦΕ(&∀>#4Γ%34∋∃(
∋. (54Β∀#3Φ(6
ι(( Κ∗+∋(743%#(∀?3∀(%#3≅7Α5∋Ξ()∗+∀,(!∋#∀#∋Ε(!6(αη474∀+Β#∀Ε(−ΨΝΟβ6(Υ53∀#∃%34Γ%?(>%#%(?Α>∀#%#(∀5(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(7%#7∀5%#4∋(∀∃(Κ∋5∋+Β4%(
7∋∃(∀∃.∋ΙΑ∀(∀∃(&∀#∀72∋?(2Α+%∃∋?6(!∀#∃%∀#&∋()∀∗+#,&∋−.∀./∃#0∃.1∋2αΝΠβΕ(Νϕ0∆ΝΡΘ6(
Ν6( Υ#3≅7Α5∋(&∀(#∀.5∀ϑ4∗∃(>#∋&Α73∋(&∀(?Α(4∃Γ∀?34/%74∗∃(3∀#+4∃%&%(>%#%(∋>3%#(%5(3≅3Α5∋(&∀(+%/≅?3∀#(∀∃(η∀#∀72∋?(_Α+%∃∋?Ε(
!∀#∃
6
−6( ΥΒ∋/%&∋Ε(7%∃&4&%3∋(%(+%/≅?3∀#(∀∃(η∀#∀72∋?(_Α+%∃∋?Ε(
!∀#∃%
(
177
Introducción
95(%#3≅7Α5∋(ΙΑ∀(?∀(>#∀?∀∃3%(%(7∋∃34∃Α%74∗∃(34∀∃∀(
7∋+∋(∋ΒΗ∀34Γ∋(7∀∃3#%5( 2%7∀#( Α∃( %∃Χ54?4?( 7#≅347∋(
?∋Β#∀(∀5(∃4Γ∀5(&∀(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(∀∃(ΙΑ∀(?∀(∀∃7Α∀∃∆
3#%∃( %73Α%5+∀∃3∀( 5∋?( 7∀∃3#∋?( >∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋?( ∀∃(
Κ∋5∋+Β4%Ε(Φ(5%(#∀5%74∗∃(ΙΑ∀( ∀ϑ4?3∀( 7∋∃( 5%( >#∋∆
3∀774∗∃(&∀( 5∋?( &∀#∀72∋?(2Α+%∃∋?( >∋#( >%#3∀( &∀5(
9?3%&∋Ε(7∋+∋(Α∃(4+>∀#%34Γ∋(7∋∃?343Α74∋∃%5( ΙΑ∀(
#∀ΙΑ4∀#∀(&∀(?Α(>5∀∃∋(7Α+>54+4∀∃3∋6
Τ%#%( 7Α+>54#( 7∋∃( ∀?∀( ∋ΒΗ∀34Γ∋Ε(∀5( ∀?3Α&4∋( ∀+∆
>4∀,%(7∋∃(Α∃( %∃Χ54?4?(?∋Β#∀(5%( >#∋Β5∀+Χ347%(&∀5(
2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(7%#7∀5%#4∋Ε(#∀?%53%∃&∋(ΙΑ∀( ∀?3%(∀?(
Α∃%(?43Α%74∗∃(>∀#+%∃∀∃3∀Ε(#∀7Α##∀∃3∀(Φ(7∋∃(3∀∃∆
&∀∃74%(%(>#∋.Α∃&4,%#?∀Ε(5∋(ΙΑ∀(2%(∋7%?4∋∃%&∋(Α∃%(
7#4?4?(∀∃(+%3∀#4%(&∀(&∀#∀72∋(4∃3∀#∃%74∋∃%5(&∀(5∋?(
&∀#∀72∋?(2Α+%∃∋?(α
&&
%∋
((
%
βΕ(ΙΑ∀(2%(?Α>Α∀?3∋(
∃∀7∀?%#4%+∀∃3∀(Α∃%(#∀?>∋∃?%Β454&%&(&∀5(9?3%&∋Ε(
>#∋&Α73∋(?4∃(&Α&%( &∀5(∀?3%&∋(&∀( 7∋?%?(4∃7∋∃?34∆
3Α74∋∃%5(ΙΑ∀(.Α∀(∀?3%Β5∀74&∋(>∋#(5%(Κ∋#3∀(Κ∋∃?34∆
3Α74∋∃%5(%(3#%ΓΛ?(&∀(5%(?∀∃3∀∃74%(Μ∆ΝΟΠ(&∀(ΝΘΘΡ6
Τ∋?3∀#4∋#+∀∃3∀(?∀(%Β∋#&%(∀5( &∀?%##∋55∋(24?3∗#4∆
7∋(&∀(5∋?(7∀∃3#∋?(&∀( #∀75Α?4∗∃(∀∃( ∀5(>%≅?( ∀∃(&∋?(
+∋+∀∃3∋?Ξ(∀5(>#4+∀#∋Ε(%∃3∀?(&∀(5%(Κ∋∃?343Α74∗∃(
Τ∋5≅347%(&∀(ΝΘΘΝΕ(7Α%∃&∋(∀5(3∀+%(&∀(5∋?(&∀#∀72∋?(
2Α+%∃∋?( ∃∋( ?∀( ∀∃7∋∃3#%Β%( 3%∃( &∀?%##∋55%&∋Ε(
>Α∀?(5%(∃∋#+%34Γ4&%&(>∀∃%5( ?∀( ∀∃+%#7%Β%( &∀∃∆
3#∋( &∀( 5%( Κ∋∃?343Α74∗∃( &∀( ΝΡΡ0Ε( 7%#%73∀#4,%&%(
>∋#(Α∃%(∃∋3%Β5∀(%Α?∀∃74%(&∀(∃∋#+%?(7∋∃?343Α74∋∆
∃%5∀?(∀∃(∀?3%(+%3∀#4%κ(∀5(?∀/Α∃&∋Ε(&∀?>ΑΛ?(&∀(5%(
Κ%#3%(Τ∋5≅347%(&∀( ΝΘΘΝΕ(&∋∃&∀(?∀( .4Η%∃( >%#Χ+∀∆
3#∋?(75%#∋?(?∋Β#∀(5%(>∀#?∋∃%(2Α+%∃%Ε(?Α(&∀#∀72∋(
%(5%(54Β∀#3%&(Φ(5%(&4/∃4&%&6(
9?3∋( 7∋∃55∀Γ%( %?Α+4#( ∀5( ∀?3Α&4∋( & ∀( 5%?( >#4∃74∆
>%5∀?(∃∋74∋∃∀?( ?∋Β#∀( ∀5( &∀#∀72∋( 7%#7∀5%#4∋Ε( ∀?∆
>∀7≅.47%+∀∃3∀( %ΙΑ∀55%?( #∀5%74∋∃%&%?( 7∋∃( ∀5( 2%∆
74∃%+4∀∃3∋6(η∀(%2≅(ΙΑ∀(∀5(>#4+∀#( 7∋∃7∀>3∋(ΙΑ∀(
?∀( %Β∋#&%( ∀?( ∀5( 3#%3%+4∀∃3∋( >∀∃43∀ ∃74%#4∋Ε( >∋#(
7Α%∃3∋(∀∃(Λ5(?∀(2%Β5%(?∋Β#∀(5∋?(+∀7%∃4?+∋?(Α34∆
54,%&∋?(>%#%(ΙΑ∀(∀5(4∃3∀#∃∋(?Α>∀#∀(?Α(7∋∃&474∗∃(
>∀∃%5( Φ( >Α∀&%( +∀Η∋#%#( ?Α( 7%54&%&(&∀( Γ4&%( Α∃%(
Γ∀,(2%Φ%(>%/%&∋(5%( 7∋∃&∀∃%6(:∀(>%?%(∀∃?∀/Α4&%(
%5(&∀?%##∋55∋(ΗΑ#4?>#Α&∀∃74%5(#∀?>∀73∋(%( 5∋?(&∀∆
#∀72∋?( 2Α+%∃∋?( Φ( ?Α( Γ4∋5%74∗∃(∀∃( 5∋?( 7∀∃3#∋?(
>∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋?Ε(3∋+%∃&∋(7∋+∋(Β%?∀(5%(?∀∃3∀∃74%(
Μ∆ΝΟΠ(&∀(ΝΘΘΡΕ(∀∃(5%(7Α%5(?∀(&∀75%#%(∀5(∀?3%&∋(&∀(
7∋?%?(4∃7∋∃?343Α74∋∃%5Ε(7∋+∋(7∋∃?∀7Α∀∃74%(&∀(5%(
/#%Γ∀(7#4?4?(7%#7∀5%#4%(>#∋&Α74&%(>∋#(∀5(2%74∃%∆
+4∀∃3∋6(9∃( ∀?3∀(%>%#3%&∋(?∀(7∋∃?4&∀#%∃(5%?( #%∆
,∋∃∀?(ΙΑ∀(∀?/#4+4∗(5%( :%5%(Κ∋∃?343Α74∋∃%5(>%#%(
3∋+%#(&472%( &∀74?4∗∃Ε( %( 5%( Γ∀,( ΙΑ∀( ?∀( %∃%54,%∃(
>∋?3∀#4∋#∀?( ?∀∃3∀∃74%?( ∀∃( 5%?( ΙΑ∀( ?∀( #%34.47%( 5∋(
+∀∃74∋∃%&∋(%∃3∀#4∋#+∀∃3∀6
Σ%?(7∋∃75Α?4∋∃∀?(#∀.5∀Η%∃(∀∃(?Α(7∋∃ΗΑ∃3∋(∀5(%53∋(
∃4Γ∀5(&∀(4∃∀.474∀∃74%(7∋∃(ΙΑ∀(2%∃(%73Α%&∋(5∋?(>∋∆
&∀#∀?( ∀Η∀7Α34Γ∋( Φ( 5∀/4?5%34Γ∋(∀∃( 5%( ?∋5Α74∗∃( &∀(
5%( 7#4?4?( 7%#7∀5%#4%( ∋#4/4∃%&%( >∋#( ∀5( %53∋( ∃4Γ∀5(
&∀(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋Ε(Φ(5%(∃∀7∀?4&%&( &∀( ∀+>#∀∃&∀#(
%774∋∃∀?(%.4#+%34Γ%?Ε(54Β#∀?(&∀5( &4?7Α#?∋( >#∋>∋∆
?434Γ∋(ΙΑ∀( ∃∋( 2%7∀( ∋3#%( 7∋?%( ΙΑ∀( ?4+>54.47%#( ∀5(
>#∋Β5∀+%(∀∃(Γ∀,(&∀(?∋5Α74∋∃%#5∋6
El hacinamiento carcelario en Colombia
95(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(7%#7∀5%#4∋(∀∃(Κ∋5∋+Β4%(∀?(Α∃%(
?43Α%74∗∃(>∀#+%∃∀∃3∀Ε(#∀7Α##∀∃3∀(Φ(7∋∃(3∀∃&∀∃∆
74%( %( >#∋.Α∃&4,%#?∀Ε( 5∋( ΙΑ∀( 2%( ∋7%?4∋∃%&∋( Α∃%(
7#4?4?(∀∃(+%3∀#4%(&∀(&∀#∀72∋(4∃3∀#∃%74∋∃%5(&∀(5∋?(
&∀#∀72∋?(2Α+%∃∋?Ε(ΙΑ∀( 2%( ?Α>Α∀?3∋( ∃∀7∀?%#4%∆
+∀∃3∀(Α∃%(#∀?>∋∃?%Β454&%&(&∀5(9?3%&∋(Φ(7∋∃55∀∆
Γ∗(#∀7Α##4#(%(5%(.4/Α#%(&∀5(%0∃.+&∋+%∋,&0.0∋#/,&/0∃#3
Criterio Jurídico Garantista. (Jul.-Dic. de 2015). Vol. 8, n.o 13, 176-189.
issn
: 2145-3381. Bogotá: Universidad Autónoma de Colombia.
)∗+,−,&.∋/01∗2∋).+∗+.
178
∃),#&/.4(∀?3%Β5∀74&%(>∋#(5%(Κ∋#3∀(Κ∋∃?343Α74∋∃%5(
∀∃(5%(?∀∃3∀∃74%(Μ∆ΝΟΠ(&∀(ΝΘΘΡ6
9?3∋(55∀Γ%( %(>∀∃?%#( ΙΑ∀(5%(>∋5≅347%( 7#4+4∃%5(7∋∆
5∋+Β4%∃%Ε(%Α∃%&%(%(5%?(+%5%?(>#Χ7347%?(>∀∃43∀∃∆
74%#4%?(7∋+∋( 5%(7∋##Α>74∗∃Ε(7∋∃?343ΑΦ∀(Α∃%( Γ4∋∆
5%74∗∃(>∀#+%∃∀∃3∀(&∀(5∋?(&∀#∀72∋?(2Α+%∃∋?6(η∀(
4/Α%5(.∋#+%Ε(?∀(>5%∃3∀%(7∗+∋(5%(>#∋Β5∀+Χ347%(&∀(
5∋?(7∀∃3#∋?(>∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋?(∋Β∀&∀7∀(>#∀74?%+∀∃3∀(
%(5%(%Α?∀∃74%(&∀(Α∃%(>∋5≅347%( &∀(9?3%&∋(75%#%(∀∃(
+%3∀#4%(&∀(+%∃∀Η∋(&∀( 5∋?(#∀7Α#?∋?(Φ( &∀(5%(Βλ?∆
ΙΑ∀&%(&∀(#∀?∋74%54,%74∗∃(&∀5(4∃&4Γ4&Α∋6(
η∀(%7Α∀#&∋(7∋∃(Υ#%∃/∋(α−ΨΝΠβΕ(∀5(∃4Γ∀5(&∀(2%74∃%∆
+4∀∃3∋(∀∃(∀5(−ΨΝ−(∀#%(&∀(5∋?(+Χ?(/#%Γ∀?(αΟΨΕ0µβΕ(
>Α∀?( ∀∃( Α∃%( 7%>%74&%&( &∀( ϕΟ60−Ψ( 7Α>∋?( 2%Β≅%(
ΝΝΠ6ΡΡ[(>∀#?∋∃%?(#∀75Α4&%?6( 9∃( %/∋?3∋(&∀( −ΨΝ[(
∀5(∃?343Α3∋(=%74∋∃%5(Τ∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋(Φ(Κ%#7∀5%#4∋(
α
3,∀∗∃
β(#∀Γ∀5%(Α∃(≅∃&47∀(/∀∃∀#%5(&∀(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(
&∀5(Ο−ΕϕµΕ(5∋(ΙΑ∀(&∀+Α∀?3#%(ΙΑ∀(χ5%(?43Α%74∗∃(&∀(
4∃&4/∃4&%&(∀∃(5%(7Α%5(?∀(∀∃7∋∃3#%Β%∃(5%?(>∀#?∋∃%?(
>#4Γ%&%?(&∀(54Β∀#3%&(∀∃(∀5(>%≅?δ(7ΑΦ∋?(&∀#∀72∋?(?∀(
ΒΑ?7∗(>#∋3∀/∀#(7∋∃(∀5(∀?3%&∋(&∀(7∋?%?(4∃7∋∃?343Α∆
74∋∃%5(∀?3Χ(5∀Η∋?(&∀(?Α>∀#%#?∀(?4(∃∋(?∀(2%7∀∃(7%+∆
Β4∋?(?Α?3%∃74%5∀?(∀∃(5%(>∋5≅347%(7%#7∀5%#4%6(
Desarrollo histórico de los centros de re-
clusión en Colombia
9ϑ>Α∀?3%( 5%( >#∋Β5∀+Χ347%( &∀( 5∋?( 7∀∃3#∋?( >∀∆
∃43∀∃74%#4∋?Ε(∀?( &∀( ?∀ν%5%#(ΙΑ∀(∀5( ∋#4/∀∃( &∀( ∀?∆
3∋?(?∀(#∀+∋∃3%(%(5%(55∀/%&%(&∀(5∋?(∀?>%ν∋5∀?(%(
Υ+Λ#47%Ε(>∋#( 7Α%∃3∋( ∀∃( 5%( Λ>∋7%( >#∀7∋5∋+Β4∃%(
5%(7∋+Α∃4&%&( 4∃&≅/∀∃%(724Β72%(?4( Β4∀∃(Φ%( 3∀∃≅%(
&∀?%##∋55%&%(74∀#3%(χ5∀/4?5%74∗∃(74Γ45(Φ(>∀∃%5δΕ(∃∋(
7∋∃3∀+>5%Β%( 5%( #∀75Α?4∗∃( 7∋+∋( Α∃( +∀7%∃4?+∋(
&∀(7%?34/∋(αΥ7∋?3%Ε(ΝΘΘ0β6
∴%(∀∃( 5%( Λ>∋7%( #∀>ΑΒ547%∃%Ε( ∀?>∀7≅.47%+∀∃3∀( ∀5(
Ν[(&∀(+%#,∋(&∀(ΝΡ−ΡΕ(:4+∗∃(ς∋5≅Γ%#(7#∀%(5∋?(55%∆
+%&∋?(Τ#∀?4&4∋?(Κ∋##∀774∋∃%5∀?( >%#%( 7%&%( Α∃%(
&∀(5%?(7%>43%5∀?(&∀(>#∋Γ4∃74%(ΦΕ(+∀?∀?(+Χ?(3%#&∀Ε(
&473%(Α∃( ∃Α∀Γ∋(&∀7#∀3∋(ΙΑ∀(∀?3%Β5∀7∀(5%(>#4?4∗∃(
?∋5∋(>∋#(∋#&∀∃( &∀(%Α3∋#4&%&(7∋+>∀3∀∃3∀(αΥ7∋?∆
3%Ε(ΝΘΘ0β6
Σ∋?(7∀∃3#∋?( >∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋?( 7∋Β#%∃( Γ4/∋#(%(>%#∆
34#(&∀(5∋?(%ν∋?(ΝΡΠϕ(Φ(ΝΡΠΡ(7∋∃(∀5(&∀?%##∋55∋(&∀(
Γ%#4∋?(%7∋∃3∀74+4∀∃3∋?Ε(7∋+∋(5%(7#∀%74∗∃(α%&∋>∆
74∗∃Ε(%>#∋Β%74∗∃β(&∀5(>#4+∀#(Κ∗&4/∋(Τ∀∃%5(7∋∆
95(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(7%#7∀5%#4∋(∀∃(Κ∋5∋+Β4%(
∀?(Α∃%(?43Α%74∗∃(>∀#+%∃∀∃3∀Ε(#∀7Α##∀∃3∀(
Φ(7∋∃(3∀∃&∀∃74%(%(>#∋.Α∃&4,%#?∀Ε(
5∋(ΙΑ∀(2%(∋7%?4∋∃%&∋(Α∃%(7#4?4?(∀∃(
+%3∀#4%(&∀(&∀#∀72∋(4∃3∀#∃%74∋∃%5(&∀(
5∋?(&∀#∀72∋?(2Α+%∃∋?Ε(ΙΑ∀(2%(?Α>Α∀?3∋(
∃∀7∀?%#4%+∀∃3∀(Α∃%(#∀?>∋∃?%Β454&%&(&∀5(
9?3%&∋(Φ(7∋∃55∀Γ∗(#∀7Α##4#(%(5%(.4/Α#%(&∀5(
%0∃.+&∋+%∋,&0.0∋#/,&/0∃#∃),#&/.4(∀?3%Β5∀74&%(
>∋#(5%(Κ∋#3∀(Κ∋∃?343Α74∋∃%5(∀∃(5%(
?∀∃3∀∃74%(Μ∆ΝΟΠ(&∀(ΝΘΘΡ6
Υ53∀#∃%34Γ%?(>%#%(?Α>∀#%#(∀5(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(7%#7∀5%#4∋(∀∃(Κ∋5∋+Β4%(7∋∃(∀∃.∋ΙΑ∀(∀∃(&∀#∀72∋?(2Α+%∃∋?
Criterio Jurídico Garantista. (Jul.-Dic. de 2015). Vol. 8, n.o 13, 176-189.
issn
: 2145-3381. Bogotá: Universidad Autónoma de Colombia.
179
5∋+Β4%∃∋(∀∃(∀5(ΙΑ∀(?∀(4∃3#∋&Α7∀(7∋+∋(Α∃∋(&∀(5∋?(
7%?34/∋?(5%( >∀∃%( >#4Γ%34Γ%(&∀(5%( 54Β∀#3%&6( γ3#%?(
%774∋∃∀?( ΙΑ∀( .Α∀#∋∃( 7∋∃.∋#+%∃&∋( Α∃( >#4+∀#(
7Α∀#>∋( ∃∋#+%34Γ∋( #∀5%74∋∃%&∋( 7∋∃( 5∋?( 7∀∃3#∋?(
&∀(#∀75Α?4∗∃(5%?(?∀ν%5%(6(ΝΨ[βΞ
Σ%(∀ϑ>∀&474∗∃( &∀5( &∀7#∀3∋(#∀/5%+∀∃3%#4∋( &∀(5∋?(
>#∀?4&4∋?(Α#Β%∃∋?Ε(&∀5(Ο( &∀(∀∃∀#∋(&∀( ΝΡΠϕκ(∀5(&∀∆
7#∀3∋(&∀(.∋#+%74∗∃(&∀(&4?3#43∋?(>∀∃%5∀?Ε(&∀5(Νϕ(&∀(
%Β#45(&∀(ΝΡΠΡκ(5%(5∀Φ(ΙΑ∀(∀?3%Β5∀74∗(7%?%?(&∀(7%?34∆
/∋Ε(&∀5(ΠΨ(&∀(+%Φ∋(&∀(ΝΡΠΡκ(∀5(&∀7#∀3∋(ΙΑ∀(#∀/5%∆
+∀∃3∗(5%(%&+4∃4?3#%74∗∃(&∀(7%&%(∀?3%Β5∀74+4∀∃3∋Ε(
&∀5(Νϕ(&∀(%Β#45(&∀(ΝΡΠΘΕ(∀∃3#∀(∋3#∋?6
∴%(∀∃( ∀5( ?4/5∋(
44
Ε( ∀5(
3#%ΓΛ?( &∀5( η∀7#∀3∋( ΝϕΝ0( &∀( ΝΘ0Ψ( +∋&4.47%( 5%(
∀?3#Α73Α#%( 7%#7∀5%#4%( 2%74∀∃&∋( 7%+Β4∋?( ∀∃( 5%?(
&4.∀#∀∃3∀?( Χ#∀%?Ε( ∀Η∀#74∀∃&∋( ∀5( ( +%∃∀Η∋( &∀( 5∋?(
∀?3%Β5∀74+4∀∃3∋?( 7%#7∀5%#4∋?κ( %?4+4?+∋Ε( .Α∀#∋∃(
7#∀%&∋?(5∋?(?∀#Γ474∋?(+Λ&47∋?(Φ(?∋74%5∀?(Φ(5%(%?4?∆
3∀∃74%(∀&Α7%34Γ%(7∋+∋(+∀7%∃4?+∋?(>%#%(+∀Η∋#%#(
∀5(∃4Γ∀5(&∀(?∋74%54,%74∗∃( &∀(5∋?(#∀75Α?∋?(αΜΛ55∀,Ε(
ΝΘΘ0β6
(
ς%Η∋( 5%( ∃Α∀Γ%( ?43Α%74∗∃( ΗΑ#≅&47%( &∀3∀#+4∃%&%(
>∋#(5%( Κ∋∃?343Α74∗∃(Τ∋5≅347%(&∀(ΝΘΘΝΕ( Κ∋5∋+Β4%(
%?Α+∀(∀5(#∀3∋(&∀(#∀&4?∀ν%#(5%(>∋5≅347%(7%#7∀5%#4%(
3∋+%∃&∋(7∋+∋(>#4∃74>4∋?(5∋?(∀?3%Β5∀74&∋?(∀∃(&4∆
72%(Κ%#3%Ε( ΒΑ?7%∃&∋( 7∋∃(∀55∋(5∋/#%#(Α∃( 7Α∀#>∋(
∃∋#+%34Γ∋(2∋+∋/Λ∃∀∋( ∀∃( ∀5( +%#7∋( &∀( 5∋?(
&&
%∋
((
6
Ε(%?>∀73∋(ΙΑ∀( ∃∋(2%Β≅%(?4&∋( 7∋∃?4&∀#%&∋(7∋∃(
>#∋.Α∃&4&%&(Φ(ΙΑ∀(%2∋#%(2%7≅%(>%#3∀(&∀(5∋?(4+>∀∆
#%34Γ∋?(7∋∃?343Α74∋∃%5∀?6(Κ∋+∋(7∋∃?∀7Α∀∃74%(&∀(
∀55∋(∀∃(ΝΘΘΠ(?∀(7#∀%(∀5(
3,∀∗∃
(Φ(∀5( Κ∗&4/∋(Τ∀∃4∆
3∀∃74%#4∋(Φ(Κ%#7∀5%#4∋(αΥ7∋?3%Ε(ΝΘΘ0β6
!4∃%5+∀∃3∀Ε(%(3#%ΓΛ?(&∀( 5%(Σ∀Φ(ΝϕΨΘ(&∀(−ΨΝ[(?∀(
24,∋(Α∃%(#∀.∋#+%(∃∋#+%34Γ%(7∋∃(5%(ΙΑ∀(?∀(ΒΑ?7∗(
+∀Η∋#%#(Φ(>#∋.Α∃&4,%#( ∀5( 3∀+%( &∀5( 3#%Β%Η∋(Φ(5%(
#∀?∋74%54,%74∗∃(&∀(5∋?(4∃3∀#∃∋?6(9?3∋?(∀5∀+∀∃3∋?(
∃∋#+%34Γ∋?(Φ(?Α(#∀5%74∗∃(7∋∃(5∋?(
&&
%∋
((
6
(?∀(Γ∀∆
#Χ∃(7∋∃(+%Φ∋#(>#∋.Α∃&4&%&(7Α%∃&∋(?∀(%∃%547∀(∀5(
+%#7∋(ΗΑ#≅&47∋(&∀(5%?(7Χ#7∀5∀?(∀∃(Κ∋5∋+Β4%6(
Principales nociones que hacen parte del
derecho carcelario
Hacinamiento carcelario
Τ%#%(8∋Β5∀?(α−ΨΝΝβ(∀5(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(7%#7∀5%#4∋(∀?(
5%(χ%7Α+Α5%74∗∃(∋(%+∋∃3∋∃%+4∀∃3∋(&∀(>∀#?∋∃%?(
∀∃(∀5(?4?3∀+%(7%#7∀5%#4∋(7∋∃?4&∀#%&∋(∀ϑ7∀?4Γ∋(∀∃(
#∀5%74∗∃(7∋∃(5%(7%>%74&%&(+Χϑ4+%(&∀(5∋?(∀?3%Β5∀∆
74+4∀∃3∋?(>∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋?δ(α>6([ΨϕβΕ(5∋(ΙΑ∀(/∀∃∀#%(
7∋+∋(7∋∃?∀7Α∀∃74%(5%( ΓΑ5∃∀#%74∗∃( &∀( 5∋?( &∀#∀∆
72∋?(2Α+%∃∋?(+Χ?(.Α∃&%+∀∃3%5∀?(7∋+∋(∀5(&∀#∀∆
72∋(%(5%(Γ4&%Ε(5%(&4/∃4&%&(2Α+%∃%Ε( ∀5(&∀#∀72∋( %(
5%(4∃34+4&%&Ε(∀376
:∀/λ∃(Υ#4%?( α−ΨΝΠβΕ( ∀5(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(7%#7∀5%#4∋(
∀?(Α∃∋( &∀(5∋?( .∀∃∗+∀∃∋?(+Χ?(7∋+>5∀Η∋?( Φ(/#%∆
Γ∀?(>∋#(7Α%∃3∋(?4/∃4.47%( 5%(>Λ#&4&%( &∀(&∀#∀72∋?(
&∀(5∋?(4∃3∀#∃∋?Ε(3%5∀?(7∋+∋(7%#∀∃74%(&∀(%3∀∃74∗∃(
+Λ&47%Ε( /∀∃∀#%74∗∃( &∀( ∀∃.∀#+∀&%&∀?( &∀( 3∋&∋(
34>∋Ε(>#∋54.∀#%74∗∃( &∀( 5%(7∋##Α>74∗∃(7∋+∋(>#4∃∆
74>%5(+∀7%∃4?+∋( >%#%( ?∋Β#∀Γ4Γ4#(Φ(&∀?4/Α%5&%&(
∀∃(∀5( 3#%3%+4∀∃3∋(&∀( 5∋?(4∃3∀#∃∋?Ε(5∋( ΙΑ∀(4+>∋∆
?4Β4543%(ΙΑ∀(?∀(&Λ(Α∃(Γ∀#&%&∀#∋(>#∋7∀?∋(&∀(#∀?∋∆
74%54,%74∗∃6(Τ#∋.Α∃&4,%∃&∋Ε(_∋.∀#( α−ΨΝ−β(&∀?3%∆
7%(ΙΑ∀(∀5(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(7%#7∀5%#4∋(∋Β∀&∀7∀(%(5%?(
?4/Α4∀∃3∀?(7%Α?%?Ξ(
π( ∃∀.474∀∃74%(/∀∃∀#%5(∀∃(5%(ΗΑ?3474%(>∀∃%56
π( 95(34>∋(&∀(>∋5≅347%?(>λΒ547%?(>Α∃434Γ%?(ΙΑ∀(3∀#∆
+4∃%∃(7∋∃( ∀5(Α?∋(∀ϑ7∀?4Γ∋(&∀( 5%(&∀3∀∃74∗∃(Φ(
∀∃7%#7∀5%+4∀∃3∋(∀∃(5%?(∀3%>%?(>#∀Γ4%?(%5(ΗΑ474∋6
Criterio Jurídico Garantista. (Jul.-Dic. de 2015). Vol. 8, n.o 13, 176-189.
issn
: 2145-3381. Bogotá: Universidad Autónoma de Colombia.
)∗+,−,&.∋/01∗2∋).+∗+.
180
(π( Τ#∀?∀∃74%(&∀(Α∃%(χ4∃%&∀7Α%&%(>#∀Γ4?4∗∃(5∀/4?∆
5%34Γ%(&∀(+∀&4&%?(Φ(?%∃74∋∃∀?(∃∋(>#4Γ%34Γ%?(&∀(
5%(54Β∀#3%&Ε(Φ(5%(.%53%(&∀(>∋5≅347%?(Φ(&4#∀73#47∀?(
75%#%?(&∀(4+>∋?474∗∃(&∀(>∀∃%?( ΙΑ∀(∀?34+Α5∀∃(
5%(%>547%74∗∃(&∀(∀?%?(+∀&4&%?(Φ(?%∃74∋∃∀?δ(α>6(
ϕβ6
π( Τ#∋Β5∀+%?( >#∋.Α∃&∋?( &∀( /#%∃&∀?( ?∀73∋#∀?(
+%#/4∃%&∋?(Φ(∀ϑ75Α4&∋?(&∀(5%(?∋74∀&%&6(
π( ΥΑ?∀∃74%(∀( 4∃∀.474∀∃74%( &∀( +∀&4&%?(ΙΑ∀(ΒΑ?∆
ΙΑ∀∃(>#∀Γ∀∃4#(5%(#∀4∃74&∀∃74%6
(π( ΥΑ?∀∃74%(&∀( >#∋/#%+%?( #∀5%74∋∃%&∋?( 7∋∃( 5%(
>Α∀?3%(∀∃(54Β∀#3%&6(
(π( ∃?Α.474∀∃74%(&∀( ∀?3%Β5∀74+4∀∃3∋?(7%#7∀5%#4∋?(
Φ(&∀(#∀7Α#?∋?(>%#%(5∋?(+4?+∋?6
(
Política criminal
9?(∀?∀(7∋∃ΗΑ∃3∋(&∀(+∀&4&%?(ΙΑ∀(34∀∃&∀∃(%(&∀.4∃4#(
5%(.∋#+%(7∋+∋(∀5(9?3%&∋(Γ%(%(%.#∋∃3%#(∀5(3∀+%(&∀(
5%(7#4+4∃%54&%&(3%∃3∋( &∀?&∀(∀5(Χ+Β43∋( &∀5(&∀543∋(
7∋+∋(&∀5(+4?+∋(&∀54∃7Α∀∃3∀( α7#4+4∃%54&%&βΕ(%?≅(
7∋+∋(5%(7#4+4∃%54,%74∗∃Ε(ΙΑ∀(∃∋(∀?(∋3#%(7∋?%(ΙΑ∀(
5%( >∀∃%( Φ( 5%( .Α∃74∗∃( #∀?∋74%54,%&∋#%( ΙΑ∀( 34∀∃∀(
∀?3%(α∃?343Α3∋( 8∋?%#4?3%(&∀(Υ774∗∃( :∋74%5(θ
5∗
6
+∗5
ρΕ(−ΨΝΝβ6(9∃(∀?3%(5≅∃∀%(?∋∃(Γ%#4%?(5%?(&∀.4∃4∆
74∋∃∀?(ΙΑ∀(?∀(2%∃(&%&∋(%5(#∀?>∀73∋6
η∀?&∀( Α∃( %?>∀73∋( >∋5≅347∋( ?∀( >∋≅%( &∀.4∃4#(
7∋+∋(%ΙΑ∀5( 7∋∃ΗΑ∃3∋(&∀(+∀&4&%?( Φ(7#43∀#4∋?(&∀(
7%#Χ73∀#( ΗΑ#≅&47∋Ε( ?∋74%5Ε( ∀&Α7%34Γ∋Ε( ∀7∋∃∗+47∋(
Φ( &∀( ≅∃&∋5∀( ?4+45%#Ε(∀?3%Β5∀74&∋?( >∋#( 5∋?( >∋&∀∆
#∀?(>λΒ547∋?(>%#%(>#∀Γ∀∃4#(Φ(#∀%774∋∃%#(.#∀∃3∀(%5(
.∀∃∗+∀∃∋(7#4+4∃%5Ε(7∋∃( ∀5(.4∃(&∀( +%∃3∀∃∀#(Β%Η∋(
5≅+43∀?(3∋5∀#%Β5∀?(5∋?(≅∃&47∀?(&∀(7#4+4∃%54&%&(∀∃(
Α∃%(&∀3∀#+4∃%&%(?∋74∀&%&(ας∋#Η%Ε(−ΨΨΠ%Ε(>6(−−β6
Μ%5(7∋+∋( ?∀(∀∃34∀∃&∀Ε( 5%(>∋5≅347%(7#4+4∃%5( ∀?(∀5(
&∀?%##∋55∋( 4∃3∀/#%5( &∀( Α∃%( ?∀#4∀( &∀( %774∋∃∀?( Φ(
+∀&4&%?(7∋∃&Α7∀∃3∀?( 3∋&%?(∀55%?( %(&4?+4∃Α4#(5%(
7#4+4∃%54&%&Ε(3∋+%∃&∋(7∋+∋(∀Η∀?(5%(>#∀Γ∀∃74∗∃Ε(
#∀>#∀?4∗∃( Φ( #∀?∋74%54,%74∗∃6(γ3#%( &∀( 5%?( &∀.4∃4∆
74∋∃∀?(&∀( >∋5≅347%( 7#4+4∃%5( 5%( 3#%∀( Κ5%Α?(8∋ϑ4∃(
α−ΨΝ−βΕ(ΙΑ4∀∃(?∀ν%5%(ΙΑ∀(5%(.∋#+%(∀∃(ΙΑ∀(?∀(&∀Β∀(
3#%3%#( %( 5%?( >∀#?∋∃%?( ΙΑ∀( Γ%∃( ∀∃( 7∋∃3#%Γ≅%( &∀(
5%?(#∀/5%?(#∀5%34Γ%?(%( 5%( 7∋∃Γ4Γ∀∃74%( ?∋74%5Ε( /∀∆
∃∀#%∃&∋(7∋∃(∀55∋(Α∃%(>∋?4Β5∀(5∀?4∗∃(∋(>Α∀?3%(∀∃(
>∀54/#∋(&∀(5%(7∋+Α∃4&%&Ε(∀?(5∋(ΙΑ∀(&∀3∀#+4∃%(∀5(
∋ΒΗ∀3∋(&∀(5%(>∋5≅347%(7#4+4∃%56(
η∀(%7Α∀#&∋( 7∋∃(5∋( %∃3∀#4∋#Ε(5%(>∋5≅347%(7#4+4∃%5(
?∀( 7∋∃.4/Α#%( 7∋+∋( ∀?7∀∃%#4∋( 4∃3∀#+∀&4∋( ∀∃3#∀(
5%(3∀∋#≅%( Φ( 5%(>#Χ7347%Ε( ∀?( &∀74#Ε(∀∃3#∀(5%(74∀∃74%(
ΗΑ#≅&47%(α7∋∃∋74+4∀∃3∋(∋ΒΗ∀34Γ∋(&∀5( &∀543∋β( Φ( 5%(
>#Χ7347%(?∋74%5(α55∀Γ%#( 4&∀%?( ∀( 4∃3∀#∀?∀?( 7∋∃7#∀∆
3∋?βΞ(χΚ∋+∋(3∀∋#≅%Ε(4∃3∀∃3%( &∀?%##∋55%#( Α∃%( ∀?∆
3#%3∀/4%(&∀74&4&%(&∀(5Α72%(7∋∃3#%(∀5( &∀543∋κ(>∀#∋(
7∋+∋(3%+Β4Λ∃(∋7Α##∀(>∋#(5∋(&∀+Χ?(∀∃(5%(>∋5≅347%Ε(
5%( #∀%54,%74∗∃( >#Χ7347%( &∀>∀∃&∀( %( +∀∃Α&∋( +Χ?(
&∀(5%?(#∀%54&%&∀?(>#∀∀ϑ4?3∀∃3∀?(ΙΑ∀(&∀(5%(7∋∃7∀>∆
74∗∃(4&∀∋5∗/47%δ(α8∋ϑ4∃Ε(ΝΘΘ−Ε(>6(ϕΘΟβ6
95(4+>∋#3%∃3∀(%>∋#3∀(&%&∋(>∋#(∀?3∀(&∋73#4∃%∃3∀(
?∀(∋#4∀∃3%(2%74%(5%(&4∃Χ+47%(>#∋>4%(&∀5(7∋∃7∀>3∋(
&∀(>∋5≅347%(7#4+4∃%5Ε(∀∃(3%∃3∋(∀5(+4?+∋(∀?(24Η∋(&∀5(
7∋∃3∀ϑ3∋(∀∃(∀5(7Α%5(?∀(∀?3Λ(%>547%∃&∋Ε(%Α∃(7Α%∃&∋(
?≅(∀?(75%#∋(ΙΑ∀(?Α(∋#4∀∃3%74∗∃(∀?3Χ(∀∃.∋7%&%(2%74%(
5%(5Α72%(7∋∃3#%(∀5(&∀543∋6(
La garantía de los derechos humanos en las
personas privadas de libertad
95(%∃Χ54?4?( Φ( >#∋.Α∃&4,%74∗∃(&∀(5∋?(
&&
%∋
((
6
(2%(
?4&∋(Α∃∋(&∀(5∋?(%?>∀73∋?( ΙΑ∀(2%(7∋Β#%&∋(+%Φ∋#(
Υ53∀#∃%34Γ%?(>%#%(?Α>∀#%#(∀5(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(7%#7∀5%#4∋(∀∃(Κ∋5∋+Β4%(7∋∃(∀∃.∋ΙΑ∀(∀∃(&∀#∀72∋?(2Α+%∃∋?
Criterio Jurídico Garantista. (Jul.-Dic. de 2015). Vol. 8, n.o 13, 176-189.
issn
: 2145-3381. Bogotá: Universidad Autónoma de Colombia.
181
4+>∋#3%∃74%(%(5∋(5%#/∋(&∀(5∋?(?4/5∋?(
44
(Φ(
443
(∀∃∆
3#∀(5%(7∋+Α∃4&%&(4∃3∀#∃%74∋∃%5Ε(∀?>∀7≅.47%+∀∃3∀(
>∋#( >%#3∀( &∀( 5%( γ#/%∃4,%74∗∃( &∀( 5%?( =%74∋∃∀?(
;∃4&%?( α
.,!
βΕ( +Χϑ4+%( ∀∃34&%&( ∀∃7%#/%&%( &∀(
2%7∀#(?∀/Α4+4∀∃3∋(%( 5%(.∋#+%(7∋+∋( 5∋?(9?3%&∋?(
2%7∀∃(∀.∀734Γ∋(∀5( %+>%#∋( %( 3%5∀?(&∀#∀72∋?Ε(%( 5%(
Γ∀,(ΙΑ∀(34∀∃∀(7∋+∋(+4?4∗∃(&∀∃Α∃74%#5∋?(%∃3∀(?Α(
∀Γ4&∀∃3∀(∋(4∃+4∃∀∃3∀(Γ4∋5%74∗∃6(
9∃( ∀?3∀(?∀∃34&∋Ε( 5%(
.,!
( α−ΨΝΝβ(&∀.4∃4∗( ΙΑ∀( 5∋?(
&&
%∋
((
6(?∋∃( 4∃?∀>%#%Β5∀?(&∀( 7Α%5ΙΑ4∀#(>∀#?∋∃%Ε(
?4∃(ΙΑ∀(∀ϑ4?3%(&4?34∃74∗∃(#∀?>∀73∋(%(?Α(∃%74∋∃%54∆
&%&Ε(%5(5Α/%#(∀∃(ΙΑ∀(?∀(∀∃7Α∀∃3#∀Ε(/Λ∃∀#∋(Α(∋#4/∀∃(
Λ3∃47∋Ε(∀∃3#∀(∋3#∋?Ε(5∋(ΙΑ∀(?4/∃4.47%(ΙΑ∀(∀?3∋?(2%∆
7∀∃(>%#3∀(&∀(5%(∃%3Α#%5∀,%(2Α+%∃%Ε(&∀(%2≅(ΙΑ∀(?∀(
3∀∃/%(∀∃(7Α∀∃3%(?Α(>#∋3∀774∗∃(7∋+∋(∋7Α##∀(7∋∃(
∀5(&∀#∀72∋(%(5%(Γ4&%Ε(∀5(3#%3∋(2Α+%∃∋(&∀7∀∃3∀Ε(5%(
&4/∃4&%&(2Α+%∃%(Φ(5%(4∃3∀/#4&%&(&∀(5%?(>∀#?∋∃%?6
!4∃%5+∀∃3∀Ε( Κ∀#&%?( α−ΨΨ[β( >5%∃3∀%( ΙΑ∀( 5%( Γ4∆
/∀∃74%(&∀( 5∋?(
&&
%∋
((
6
(?∀( ∀∃7Α∀∃3#%( 54/%&%(%(5%(
&∀+∋7#%74%Ε(∀∃(∀5( ?∀∃34&∋( &∀(ΙΑ∀(34∀∃∀( ΙΑ∀( Γ∀#(
7∋∃(∀5(34>∋(&∀(∋#&∀∃( ?∋74%5Ε( >∋5≅347∋Ε( ΗΑ#≅&47∋( Φ(
7Α53Α#%5(ΙΑ∀(4∃3∀#>#∀3%(Φ(&∀3∀#+4∃%(?Α(∃∋74∗∃(&∀(
&∀+∋7#%74%Ε(Φ( ?∋Β#∀(∀55%(>∋≅%( Β4∀∃(#∀7∋#3%#( ∋(
%+>54%#(5%(Γ4/∀∃74%(&∀(3%5∀?(&∀#∀72∋?Ε(&∀(%2≅(ΙΑ∀(
?∀%(Α∃%(7#≅347%(>∀#+%∃∀∃3∀(ΙΑ∀(Β%Η∋(∀5(7∋∃7∀>3∋(
&∀(&∀+∋7#%74%(5∋?(9?3%&∋?(7#∀∀∃(∃∋#+%?(ΙΑ∀(5∋?(
54+43∀∃6(
9?3%?(7∋∃?4&∀#%74∋∃∀?(>∋∃∀∃(&∀(+%∃4.4∀?3∋(7∗+∋(
5%(∃∋74∗∃(&∀(
&&
%∋
((
6
(∀?(Α∃(7∋∃?3#Α73∋Ε(∀∃(∀5(∀∃∆
3∀∃&4&∋(ΙΑ∀(∀?( Α∃%(7∋∃?3#Α774∗∃( ?∋74%5Ε(24?3∗#4∆
7%Ε(+%#7%&%(>∋#(5%(4∃3∀#>#∀3%74∗∃(ΙΑ∀(2%7∀∃(5∋?(
&4.∀#∀∃3∀?(9?3%&∋?(&∀(3%5∀?(&∀#∀72∋?Ε(>∀#∋( ΙΑ∀(
?4∃(&Α&%( 34∀∃∀∃( Α∃%?(#∀/5%?(+≅∃4+%?( ∀?3%Β5∀74∆
&%?(>∋#(5%(7∋+Α∃4&%&(4∃3∀#∃%74∋∃%5(%(3#%ΓΛ?(&∀(
5∋?(4∃?3#Α+∀∃3∋?(ΗΑ#≅&47∋?(Γ4∃7Α5%∃3∀?(∀∃(+%3∀∆
#4%(&∀( /%#%∃3≅%?( &∀( 5∋?( &∀#∀72∋?( &∀( 5∋?( 4∃&4Γ4∆
&Α∋?(Φ(&∀(5%(?∋74∀&%&(∀∃(/∀∃∀#%56
ς%Η∋(∀?3∋?( 7#43∀#4∋?Ε(%Β∋#&%#(5∋?(
&&
%∋
((
6
(&∀?&∀(
5%(>∀#?>∀734Γ%(&∀5(&∀#∀72∋(4∃3∀#∃%74∋∃%5(4+>547%(
3∀∃∀#(∀∃(7Α∀∃3%(5%?(&4#∀73#47∀?(∀+%∃%&%?(&∀(∋#/%∆
∃4?+∋?(7∋+∋(5%(
.,!
Ε(%(∃4Γ∀5(/5∋Β%5Ε(Φ(&∀(5%(γ#/%∆
∃4,%74∗∃(&∀(5∋?(9?3%&∋?(Υ+∀#47%∃∋?(α
.∗−
βΕ(ΙΑ4∀∆
∃∀?( 2%∃( Γ∀∃4&∋( &∀7%∃3%∃&∋(Φ( 7∋∃?∋54&%∃&∋( 5∋?(
&&
%∋
((
6
(7∋+∋(Α∃%(2∀##%+4∀∃3%(ΗΑ#≅&47%(>%#%(>#∋∆
3∀/∀#(5∋?(&∀#∀72∋?(&∀(5%?(>∀#?∋∃%?(>#4Γ%&%?(&∀(5%(
54Β∀#3%&6(Ω%5∀(&∀74#(ΙΑ∀(∀?3∋?(%>∋#3∀?(?∋∃(.#Α3∋(&∀(
5%(∀ϑ>∀#4∀∃74%(&∀(5%(/Α∀##%(ΙΑ∀(?∀(2%(Γ4Γ4&∋(3%∃3∋(
%(∃4Γ∀5(/5∋Β%5(7∋+∋(#∀/4∋∃%5Ε(&∀(%2≅(ΙΑ∀(5%?(&∀75%∆
#%74∋∃∀?(?Α#/4&%?(&∀(∀?3%?(∀∃34&%&∀?(?4#Γ%∃(7∋+∋(
>Α∃3∋(&∀(%>∋Φ∋(ΗΑ#≅&47∋(>%#%(5%( 7∋+>#∀∃?4∗∃(&∀(
5%(?43Α%74∗∃(%73Α%5(&∀(5%?(7Χ#7∀5∀?(&∀(Κ∋5∋+Β4%(∀∃(
+%3∀#4%(&∀(∀?3∋?(&∀#∀72∋?(.Α∃&%+∀∃3%5∀?6
Τ%#%( γση∋∃∀55( α−ΨΨ[β( ∀ϑ4?3∀∃( 3#∀?( ∃4Γ∀5∀?( &∀(
7%3∀/∋#≅%?( ∀∃( ∀5( +%∃∀Η∋( &∀( 5∋?( 4∃?3#Α+∀∃3∋?(
4∃3∀#∃%74∋∃%5∀?( .#∀∃3∀(%(5∋?(
&&
%∋
((
6
Ξ(5%?( /#%∃∆
&∀?(&∀75%#%74∋∃∀?(&∀(ΝΘ[ΡΕ(5∋?(/#%∃&∀?(3#%3%&∋?(
Φ(5%?(&∀75%#%74∋∃∀?(∋( &∋7Α+∀∃3∋?(∀∃( 5∋?(ΙΑ∀( ?∀(
%Β∋#&%∃(?43Α%74∋∃∀?(∀?>∀7≅.47%?(#∀5%74∋∃%&%?(7∋∃(
3%5∀?(&∀#∀72∋?6(9∃( #∀5%74∗∃( 7∋∃( 5%( >#4+∀#%( 7%∆
3∀/∋#≅%(?∀( 4&∀∃34.47%∃(5%?( &∀75%#%74∋∃∀?(ΙΑ∀(?∋∃(
.Α∃&%∃3∀?(∀∃( +%3∀#4%(&∀(&∀#∀72∋?( .Α∃&%+∀∃3%∆
5∀?(%(∃4Γ∀5(/5∋Β%5( Φ( #∀/4∋∃%5Ε( 7∋+∋( ?∋∃( 5%( η∀∆
75%#%74∗∃(;∃4Γ∀#?%5(&∀( η∀#∀72∋?(_Α+%∃∋?(Φ(5%(
η∀75%#%74∗∃(Υ+∀#47%∃%(&∀(η∀#∀72∋?(Φ( η∀Β∀#∀?(
&∀5(_∋+Β#∀6
9∃(5%( ?∀/Α∃&%(7%3∀/∋#≅%(?∀(4&∀∃34.47%∃(∀5( Τ%73∋(
∃3∀#∃%74∋∃%5( &∀( η∀#∀72∋?( Κ4Γ45∀?( Φ( Τ∋5≅347∋?(
α
∀3&∃∀
β( Φ( ∀5( Τ%73∋( ∃3∀#∃%74∋∃%5( &∀( η∀#∀72∋?(
97∋∃∗+47∋?Ε( :∋74%5∀?( Φ( ΚΑ53Α#%5∀?( α
∀3&∗5∃
β(
7∋+∋(>%#3∀(&∀5(?4?3∀+%( 4∃3∀#∃%74∋∃%5Ε(Φ(5%(Κ∋∃∆
Criterio Jurídico Garantista. (Jul.-Dic. de 2015). Vol. 8, n.o 13, 176-189.
issn
: 2145-3381. Bogotá: Universidad Autónoma de Colombia.
)∗+,−,&.∋/01∗2∋).+∗+.
182
Γ∀∃74∗∃(Υ+∀#47%∃%(Φ(∀5(Τ#∋3∋7∋5∋(Υ&474∋∃%5(%(5%(
Κ∋∃Γ∀∃74∗∃(Υ+∀#47%∃%( #∀5%34Γ%( %( 5∋?( &∀#∀72∋?(
∀7∋∃∗+47∋?Ε(?∋74%5∀?( Φ( 7Α53Α#%5∀?Ε( ∀∃(∀5(Χ+Β43∋(
#∀/4∋∃%56( !4∃%5+∀∃3∀Ε( 5%( 3∀#7∀#%( 7%3∀/∋#≅%( 7∋∆
##∀?>∋∃&∀(%(5∋?(χ&∀+Χ?(4∃?3#Α+∀∃3∋?(?∋Β#∀(&∀∆
#∀72∋?(2Α+%∃∋?(&∀&47%&∋?(%(&∀#∀72∋?(∋(>#4∃74∆
>4∋?(∀?>∀7≅.47∋?Ε(∋(5∋?(&∀#∀72∋?(&∀(&∀3∀#+4∃%&∋?(
?∀73∋#∀?(&∀(5%(?∋74∀&%&(2Α+%∃%Ε(7∋+∋(5∋?(∃4ν∋?Ε(
5∋?( 4∃&≅/∀∃%?Ε( 5∋?( 3#%Β%Η%&∋#∀?( +4/#%∃3∀?Ε( 5%?(
>∀#?∋∃%?(7∋∃(&4?7%>%74&%&Ε(5∋?( >#∀?∋?( Φ( 3%∃3∋?(
∋3#∋?δ(αγση∋∃∀55Ε(−ΨΨ[Ε(>6(Ο0β6
Ω%5∀(+∀∃74∋∃%#(∀5(>%>∀5(ΙΑ∀(2%(&∀?∀+>∀ν%&∋(5%(
.,!
Ε(%(3#%ΓΛ?(&∀( 5%( γ.474∃%( &∀5( Υ53∋( Κ∋+4?4∋
∃%&∋(&∀(5%?(=%74∋∃∀?(;∃4&%?(>%#%(5∋?(η∀#∀72∋?(
_Α+%∃∋?( α
.−∃&(
βΕ(∀∃(+%3∀#4%(&∀(%774∋∃∀?( &∀(
>#∋3∀774∗∃(&∀(5∋?(>#4?4∋∃∀#∋?(Φ(&∀( 5%(7∋+>#∀∃∆
?4∗∃( ?∋Β#∀( 5∋?( Γ∀#&%&∀#∋?( >#∋>∗?43∋?( ΙΑ∀( ?∀(
&∀Β∀∃(>∀#?∀/Α4#(7∋∃(5%( #∀75Α?4∗∃6( 9∃( ∀?3∀(?∀∃∆
34&∋Ε(%(7∋∃34∃Α%74∗∃( ?∀( &∀?7#4Β∀∃( 5∋?( >#4∃74>%∆
5∀?(>#4∃74>4∋?Ε(∃∋#+%?(+≅∃4+%?(Φ(&∀75%#%74∋∃∀?(
∀+434&%?(>%#%(5%(>#∋3∀774∗∃(&∀( 5∋?( &∀#∀72∋?( &∀(
5∋?( #∀75Α?∋?( ∀∃( ∀5( +%#7∋( &∀5( & ∀#∀72∋( 4∃3∀#∃%∆
74∋∃%56
Reglas mínimas:
((
π( Σ%(%>547%74∗∃(&∀(5%?(#∀/5%?(&∀Β∀(?∀#(4+>%#74%56
π( :∀(&∀Β∀(55∀Γ%#(Α∃(#∀/4?3#∋(&∀(5%?(>∀#?∋∃%?(&∀3∀
∃4&%?(7∋∃(?Α(4&∀∃34&%&Ε(+∋34Γ∋?(&∀(5%(&∀3∀∃74∗∃Ε(
%Α3∋#4&%&(7∋+>∀3∀∃3∀Ε(&≅%(Φ(2∋#%(&∀(4∃/#∀?∋(Φ(
?%54&%(Φ(∋#&∀∃(ΓΧ54&%(>%#%(?Α(&∀3∀∃74∗∃6(
π( :∀(&∀Β∀(2%7∀#(Α∃%(?∀>%#%74∗∃(&∀(5∋?(4∃&4Γ4&Α∋?(
>∋#(7%3∀/∋#≅%?(α?∀ϑ∋Ε(5∋?(&∀(>#4?4∗∃(>#∀Γ∀∃34Γ%Ε(
5∋?(7∋∃&∀∃%&∋?Ε(5∋?(&∀543∋?(74Γ45∀?(%>%#3∀(&∀(5∋?(
&∀543∋?(>∀∃%5∀?Ε(Η∗Γ∀∃∀?Ε(%&Α53∋?Ε(∀376β6
π( Σ%?(7∀5&%?( >%#%( 5∋?( #∀75Α?∋?( &∀Β∀∃(?∀#(4∃&4∆
Γ4&Α%5∀?(Φ(?4(∀?(∀∃(&∋#+43∋#4∋?(?∀(&∀Β∀(2%7∀#(
Α∃%(?∀5∀774∗∃(>#∀Γ4%6(
(π( Σ∋?(#∀75Α?∋?(&∀Β∀∃( #∀74Β4#(Α∃%( %54+∀∃3%74∗∃(
&∀( ΒΑ∀∃%( 7%54&%&( Φ( 7∋∃( ΒΑ∀∃%( >#∋Γ4?4∗∃( &∀(
%/Α%(>∋3%Β5∀6
π( :4(Β4∀∃(∀5(∋#&∀∃(Φ(5%(&4?74>54∃%(&∀Β∀∃(3∀∃∀#(
.4#+∀,%Ε(5∋?(+4?+∋?(&∀Β∀∃(∋#4∀∃3%#?∀( λ∃47%∆
+∀∃3∀(%( +%∃3∀∃∀#(5%( ?∀/Α#4&%&(Φ(Α∃%(ΒΑ∀∃%(
∋#/%∃4,%74∗∃(>%#%(5%(Γ4&%(∀∃(7∋+λ∃6(
π( Σ∋?( +∀&4∋?( &∀( 7∋∀#74∗∃( α∀?>∋?%?Ε( 7%&∀∃%?Ε(
/#455∋?β(∃∋(>Α∀&∀∃( Α3454,%#?∀( 7∋+∋(+∀7%∃4?∆
+∋(>%#%(%>547%#(?%∃74∋∃∀?6(
π( η∀Β∀∃(7#∀%#?∀(5∋?( +∀7%∃4?+∋?( >%#%( ΙΑ∀( 5∋?(
#∀75Α?∋?(>Α∀&%∃(3∀∃∀#(7∋∃3%73∋(7∋∃(∀5(+Α∃&∋(
∀ϑ3∀#4∋#(α.%+454%#∀?Ε(Γ4&%(&4%#4%(∋(7∋∃(?Α(9?∆
3%&∋(&∀(∋#4/∀∃β6
Principios:
(π( Μ∋&%(>∀#?∋∃%(&∀3∀∃4&%( &∀Β∀( ?∀#(3#%3%&%(2Α∆
+%∃%+∀∃3∀(Φ(7∋∃(&4/∃4&%&6
(π( Σ%(&∀3∀∃74∗∃(?∀(&∀Β∀(55∀Γ%#(%(7%Β∋(∀∃(∀?3#47∆
3∋(7Α+>54+4∀∃3∋(&∀(5%(5∀Φ(Φ(>∋#(.Α∃74∋∃%#4∋?(
7∋+>∀3∀∃3∀?6(
(π( =∋(2%Β#Χ(#∀?3#4774∗∃(∋(+∀∃∋?7%Β∋(%5/Α∃∋(&∀(
5∋?(
&&
%∋
((
6
(#∀7∋∃∋74&∋?(>∋#(∀5(9?3%&∋6(
π( Μ∋&%(&∀3∀∃74∗∃(∋( >#4?4∗∃( &∀Β∀(?∀#( ∋#&∀∃%&%(
>∋#(Α∃( ΗΑ∀,( ∋(ΙΑ∀&%#( %( .4?7%54,%74∗∃(∀.∀734Γ%(
>∋#(∀?3∀6(
(π( =∋(2%Β#Χ(&4?7#4+4∃%74∗∃(>∋#(#%,∋∃∀?(&∀(#%,%Ε(
7∋5∋#Ε(?∀ϑ∋Ε(4&4∋+%Ε(#∀54/4∗∃Ε(∋>4∃4∗∃(>∋5≅347%Ε(
∀376
Υ53∀#∃%34Γ%?(>%#%(?Α>∀#%#(∀5(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(7%#7∀5%#4∋(∀∃(Κ∋5∋+Β4%(7∋∃(∀∃.∋ΙΑ∀(∀∃(&∀#∀72∋?(2Α+%∃∋?
Criterio Jurídico Garantista. (Jul.-Dic. de 2015). Vol. 8, n.o 13, 176-189.
issn
: 2145-3381. Bogotá: Universidad Autónoma de Colombia.
183
(π( Μ∋&%(>∀#?∋∃%(&∀3∀∃4&%(∃∋(>∋Χ(?∀#(?∋+∀34&%(
%(3∋#3Α#%Ε(3#%3∋?(∋(>∀∃%?(7#Α∀5∀?Ε(4∃2Α+%∃%?(∋(
&∀/#%&%∃3∀?6(
(π( Σ%(&∀3∀∃74∗∃(∋(%##∀?3∋(&∀Β∀#Χ(?∀#(ΗΑ?34.47%&∋(∀(
4∃.∋#+%∃&∋(%5(&∀3∀∃4&∋(5%?(#%,∋∃∀?(&∀(∀?3∀6
(π( :∀(&∀Β∀( 7∋∃?3%#( ∀∃(∀5(?434∋(&∀(#∀75Α?4∗∃Ξ( 5%?(
#%,∋∃∀?(&∀5(%##∀?3∋Ε(5%(2∋#%(α%##∀?3∋Ε(3#%?5%&∋Ε(
7∋+>%#∀7∀∃74%βΕ( 4&∀∃34&%&( &∀( 5∋?( .Α∃74∋∃%∆
#4∋?(∀∃7%#/%&∋?Ε(4∃.∋#+%74∗∃( ?∋Β#∀( ∀5( 5Α/%#(
&∀(7Α?3∋&4%6(
(π( η∀Β∀#Χ∃(4∃.∋#+%#(%5(&∀3∀∃4&∋(5∋?(&∀#∀72∋?(%(
ΙΑ∀(34∀∃∀(5Α/%#6(
η∀(∋3#∋(5%&∋Ε(∀∃(∀5(+%#7∋(5∀/%5(4∃3∀#∃∋Ε(Κ∋5∋+∆
Β4%(∀∃( +%3∀#4%(&∀(&∀#∀72∋( 7%#7∀5%#4∋( Φ(?Α(#∀5%∆
74∗∃(7∋∃(5∋?(
&&
%∋
((
6
(?∀(?Α?3∀∃3%(4∃474%5+∀∃3∀(∀∃(
5%(Κ∋∃?343Α74∗∃(Τ∋5≅347%(&∀(ΝΘΘΝΕ(∀?>∀7≅.47%+∀∃∆
3∀(∀∃(5%(+%Φ∋#≅%(&∀(5∋?(55%+%&∋?(&∀#∀72∋?(&∀(>#4∆
+∀#%(/∀∃∀#%74∗∃(∋( &∀#∀72∋?( 74Γ45∀?(Φ(>∋5≅347∋?Ε(
ΙΑ∀(?∋∃(5∋?(ΙΑ∀(7∋+>#∀∃&∀∃(∀5(&∀#∀72∋(%(5%(Γ4&%(
α%#36(ΝΝβΕ( ∀5( &∀#∀72∋(%( ∃∋( ?∀#(?∋+∀34&∋( %( 3#%3∋?(
7#Α∀5∀?(∋(3∋#3Α#%?(α%#36( Ν−βΕ(∀5(&∀#∀72∋(%(#∀74Β4#(
>#∋3∀774∗∃(∀∃(∀5(+%#7∋(&∀5(&∀#∀72∋(%(5%(4/Α%5&%&(
α%#36( ΝΠβΕ( &∀#∀72∋( %( 5%( 4∃34+4&%&( >∀#?∋∃%5( α%#36(
ΝΟβ(Φ(∀5(&∀#∀72∋(%(5%(2∋∃#%(α%#36(−ΨβΕ(∀∃3#∀(∋3#∋?6
Κ∋+∋(7∋∃?∀7Α∀∃74%(&∀(∀?3∀(∃Α∀Γ∋(&∀?%##∋55∋(&∀(
5%(Κ%#3%(Τ∋5≅347%Ε(∀5(9?3%&∋(%?Α+4∗(5%(4+>5∀+∀∃∆
3%74∗∃(&∀(Α∃(∃Α∀Γ∋(?4?3∀+%(>∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋Ε(∀5(7Α%5(
?∀(Γ4∋(#∀.5∀Η%&∋(∀∃(5%(>#∋+Α5/%74∗∃(&∀(5%(Σ∀Φ(0Ο(
&∀(ΝΘΘΠ(∀∃(5%(ΙΑ∀(?∀(.4Η%(7∋+∋(.4∃%54&%&(&∀5(3#%3%∆
+4∀∃3∋(>∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋(χ%57%∃,%#(5%(#∀?∋74%54,%74∗∃(
&∀5(4∃.#%73∋#(&∀(5%(5∀Φ(>∀∃%5Ε(+∀&4%∃3∀(∀5(∀ϑ%+∀∃(
&∀( ?Α( >∀#?∋∃%54&%&( Φ( %( 3#%ΓΛ?( &∀( 5%( &4?74>54∃%Ε(
∀5(3#%Β%Η∋Ε(∀5( ∀?3Α&4∋Ε(5%(.∋#+%74∗∃(∀?>4#43Α%5Ε(5%(
7Α53Α#%Ε(∀5(&∀>∋#3∀(Φ(5%(#∀7#∀%74∗∃Ε(Β%Η∋(Α∃(∀?>≅∆
#43Α(2Α+%∃∋(Φ(?∋54&%#4∋δ(α%#36(ΝΨβ6
ΥΑ∃%&∋Ε(Γ%( ∀5( 3∀+%( &∀( 5%( >∋5≅347%( 7#4+4∃%5( 4+∆
>5∀+∀∃3%&%(>∋#(∀5(9?3%&∋(7∋5∋+Β4%∃∋Ε(ΙΑ∀(%(ΗΑ4∆
74∋(&∀(4∃Γ∀?34/%&∋#∀?(&∀5(
5∗+∗5
(α−ΨΝΝβ(∃∋(?∀(2%(
55∀Γ%&∋( %( 7%Β∋( 7∋∃( 5%( &∀Β4&%( 4∃3∀/#%54&%&Ε( >∋#(
7Α%∃3∋(∃∋( 2%( 3∀∃4&∋( ∀∃( 7Α∀∃3%( 5%(7%>%74&%&(&∀(
4∃Γ∀?34/%74∗∃( &∀5( 9?3%&∋( ∃4( 5%( 4∃.#%∀?3#Α73Α#%(
7%#7∀5%#4%Ε(5∋(ΙΑ∀( 2%( 3∀#+4∃%&∋(>∋#( /∀∃∀#%#( 5%(
7#4?4?(∀∃( ∀5(?4?3∀+%(7%#7∀5%#4∋Ε(%?>∀73∋(∀?3∀( ΙΑ∀(
?∀(3#%3%#Χ(7∋∃(+%Φ∋#(>#∋.Α∃&4&%&(∀∃(∀5(&∀?%##∋∆
55∋( ΗΑ#4?>#Α&∀∃74%5Ε( Φ%( ΙΑ∀( 5%?( %53%?( Κ∋#3∀?Ε( ∀∃(
∀?>∀74%5(5%(Κ∋#3∀(Κ∋∃?343Α74∋∃%5Ε(2%(∀+434&∋(Α∃%(
Σ%(
.,!
(&∀.4∃4∗(ΙΑ∀(5∋?(
&&
%∋
((
%
(?∋∃(
4∃?∀>%#%Β5∀?(&∀(7Α%5ΙΑ4∀#(>∀#?∋∃%Ε(
?4∃(ΙΑ∀(∀ϑ4?3%(&4?34∃74∗∃(#∀?>∀73∋(%(
?Α(∃%74∋∃%54&%&Ε(%5(5Α/%#(∀∃(ΙΑ∀(?∀(
∀∃7Α∀∃3#∀Ε(/Λ∃∀#∋(Α(∋#4/∀∃(Λ3∃47∋Ε(∀∃3#∀(
∋3#∋?Ε(5∋(ΙΑ∀(?4/∃4.47%(ΙΑ∀(∀?3∋?(2%7∀∃(
>%#3∀(&∀(5%(∃%3Α#%5∀,%(2Α+%∃%Ε(&∀(%2≅(
ΙΑ∀(?∀(3∀∃/%(∀∃(7Α∀∃3%(?Α(>#∋3∀774∗∃(
7∋+∋(∋7Α##∀(7∋∃(∀5(&∀#∀72∋(%(5%(Γ4&%Ε(
∀5(3#%3∋(2Α+%∃∋(&∀7∀∃3∀Ε(5%(&4/∃4&%&(
2Α+%∃%(Φ(5%(4∃3∀/#4&%&(&∀(5%?(>∀#?∋∃%?6
Criterio Jurídico Garantista. (Jul.-Dic. de 2015). Vol. 8, n.o 13, 176-189.
issn
: 2145-3381. Bogotá: Universidad Autónoma de Colombia.
)∗+,−,&.∋/01∗2∋).+∗+.
184
?∀#4∀(&∀(∗#&∀∃∀?(%5( ∀Η∀7Α34Γ∋(>%#%(ΙΑ∀(?∀( ?Α>∀#∀(
∀5(∀?3%&∋( &∀( 7∋?%?( 4∃7∋∃?343Α74∋∃%5Ε(7∋∃?∀7Α∀∃∆
74%( &∀( ∀?∀( +%5( &4#∀774∋∃%+4∀∃3∋( &∀( 5%( >∋5≅347%(
7#4+4∃%5(∀∃(∀5(>%≅?(α
5∗+∗5
Ε(−ΨΝΝβ6
9?3∋?(>#∋Β5∀+%?(.Α∀#∋∃( 5∋?( ΙΑ∀( ∀?34+∗( 5%(:%5%(
Κ∋∃?343Α74∋∃%5(>%#%( &∀7#∀3%#(∀5( ∀?3%&∋(&∀( 7∋?%?(
4∃7∋∃?343Α74∋∃%5Ξ(
Σ%?(7∋∃&474∋∃∀?(%73Α%5∀?(∀∃(5%?( >#4?4∋∃∀?(7∋5∋+∆
Β4%∃%?(4+>547%∃(ΙΑ∀(5∋?(Β4∀∃∀?(+≅∃4+∋?(>%#%(/%∆
#%∃34,%#(Α∃%( Γ4&%(&4/∃%(∀∃(5%(>#4?4∗∃( αΑ∃%(7∀5&%Ε(
Α∃(χ7%+%?3#∋δΕ( ∋>∋#3Α∃4&%&( &∀(3#%Β%Η%#( Φ( &∀(∀?∆
3Α&4%#β( ?∀%∃( %Β?∋5Α3%+∀∃3∀( ∀?7%?∋?6( 9∃( ∀5( +∀∆
&4∋(7%#7∀5%#4∋(∀55∋(?4/∃4.47%(ΙΑ∀(5%(&4?3#4ΒΑ74∗∃(Φ(
%?4/∃%74∗∃(&∀(∀?∋?( Β4∀∃∀?( ?∀( #∀%547∀( %( 3#%ΓΛ?( &∀(
5∋?(+∀7%∃4?+∋?(&∀( 5%( 7∋##Α>74∗∃( Φ( 5%( Γ4∋5∀∃74%6(
αΚΚ∋∃?36Ε(ΝΘΘΡ%Ε(>6(0Πβ6(
γ3#%(7∋?%(4+>∋#3%∃3∀(ΙΑ∀(#∀7%57%(5%(Κ∋#3∀(Κ∋∃?∆
343Α74∋∃%5(?∋∃(5%?(/#%Γ∀?(∋+4?4∋∃∀?(∀∃(ΙΑ∀(∀?∆
3Χ∃(4∃7Α##4∀∃&∋(5%?( &4Γ∀#?%?( %Α3∋#4&%&∀?( >λΒ54∆
7%?(∀∃7%#/%&%?(&∀(5%(>#∋3∀774∗∃( &∀(5∋?(&∀#∀72∋?(
.Α∃&%+∀∃3%5∀?(&∀(5∋?(4∃3∀#∃∋?Ε(&∀(%2≅(ΙΑ∀(∀ϑ4/∀Ε(
+%∃&%Ε(∋#&∀∃%Ε(ΙΑ∀( ?∀(#∀+∀&4∀∃(5%?(?43Α%74∋∃∀?(
>%#%(?Α>∀#%#(3%5(∀?3%&∋(&∀((4∃7∋∃?343Α74∋∃%54&%&Ε(
>Α∃3∋(∀∃(∀5(7Α%5(2%Φ(7∋∃?∀∃?∋(?∋Β#∀(∀?3∀(4∃3∀#Λ?(
?Α>∀#4∋#6
Ω%5/%(&∀74#( ΙΑ∀(2%∃(>%?%&∋(ΙΑ4∃7∀(%ν∋?( &∀?&∀(
5%(3#%?7∀∃&∀∃3%5( Φ( >∋5Λ+47%( &∀74?4∗∃(&∀(5%( :%5%(
Κ∋∃?343Α74∋∃%5(Φ( 5∋?( #∀?Α53%&∋?( ?∋∃( 5∋?( ΙΑ∀( ?∀(
%∃%54,%#Χ∃(∀∃(∀5(?4/Α4∀∃3∀(7%>≅3Α5∋Ε(∀∃(∀5(ΙΑ∀(Φ%(
?∀(>Α∀&∀(∀Γ%5Α%#(?4(?∀(?Α>∀#∗(3%5(?43Α%74∗∃(∋(,&/3
∃∀.∀#&∋0%/0)Ε( >∀#+% ∃∀7∀( 4/Α%5( ∋( >∀∋#6(Τ%#%( ∀?3∀(
%∃Χ54?4?(?∀(3∀∃Χ∃(∀∃(7Α∀∃3%(5∋?(%>∋#3∀?(&∀5(
3,
6
∀∗∃
Φ(&∀(∋3#∋?(%Α3∋#∀?(ΙΑ∀(2%∃(Γ∀∃4&∋(2%74∀∃&∋(
?∀/Α4+4∀∃3∋(%(5%(Γ4∋5%74∗∃(&∀(5∋?(&∀#∀72∋?(.Α∃∆
&%+∀∃3%5∀?(∀∃(5∋?(7∀∃3#∋?(>∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋?6
Acciones del estado para superar el estado
de cosas inconstitucional
;∃%(&∀(5%?(%774∋∃∀?(&∀5(9?3%&∋(>%#%(∀5(.4∃(∀∃(+∀∃∆
74∗∃(>#∋Γ4∀∃∀(&∀(5∋?(>5%∃∀?(&∀(&∀?%##∋55∋Ε(&∋∃&∀(
?∀(∀ϑ>∋∃∀(Α∃(&4?7Α#?∋(>#∋>∋?434Γ∋(Φ(%+>54∋(∀∃(∀5(
.∋#3%5∀74+4∀∃3∋(&∀(5∋?(&∀#∀72∋?(.Α∃&%+∀∃3%5∀?(Φ(
∀∃(5%(?Α>∀#%74∗∃(&∀(5%?(/#%Γ∀?(.%5∀∃74%?(>∋5≅347%?Ε(
∀7∋∃∗+47%?Ε(?∋74%5∀?( Φ( &∀( ΗΑ?3474%κ( >∀#∋( &∀( Α∃%(
/#%∃(4∃∀.474∀∃74%(∀∃(?Α(>Α∀?3%(∀∃(>#Χ7347%Ε(7∋∃(5∋(
7Α%5(∃∋(?∋5∋(>∀#?4?3∀∃(5∋?(>#∋Β5∀+%?Ε(?4∃∋(ΙΑ∀(?∀(
>#∋.Α∃&4,%∃(%5(>Α∃3∋(&∀(7#∀%#(Α∃%(+%Φ∋#(7#4?4?(
?∋74%5(ΦΕ(>∋#(∀∃&∀Ε(7∋∃?∀7Α∀∃74%?(∃∀/%34Γ%?(∀∃(∀5(
3#%3%+4∀∃3∋(&∀5(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(7%#7∀5%#4∋6
Υ2∋#%Ε(∀∃( 5∋(ΙΑ∀( 7∋∃74∀#∃∀(%(5∋?(>5%∃∀?(&∀(ΗΑ?∆
3474%(∀+>#∀∃&4&∋?(>∋#(5∋?(/∋Β4∀#∃∋?(>∋?3∀#4∋#∀?(
%(ΝΘΘΡΕ( ?∀( 2%∃(4&∀∃34.47%&∋(7Α%3#∋( ∀∃( 7∋∃7#∀3∋Ε(
7%&%(Α∃∋(&∀(∀55∋?(?∋>∋#3%&∋(∀∃(5%(>∋5≅347%(>λΒ54∆
7%(∀+>#∀∃&4&%(∀∃(7%&%(Α∃∋(&∀(5∋?(7Α%3#4∀∃4∋?6(95(
>#4+∀#∋Ε(&∀?%##∋55%&∋( >∋#( ∀5( )∋Β4∀#∃∋( :%+>∀#(
αΝΘΘ[∆ΝΘΘΡβΕ(?∀(Β%?∗(∀∃(∀5(5∀+%(χΗΑ?3474%(>%#%(5%(
/∀∃3∀δΕ(∀5( 7Α%5( ?∀(+%3∀#4%54,∗( ∀∃(∀5(η∋7Α+∀∃3∋(
Κ∋∃>∀?(−ϕ[[(&∀(ΝΘΘ[6(
95(?∀/Α∃&∋(>5%∃(&∀5( /∋Β4∀#∃∋(&∀(:%+>∀#(7∋∃∆
3∀+>5∗(∀5(+%∃∀Η∋(#%74∋∃%5(&∀(5∋?(#∀7Α#?∋?(ΗΑ&4∆
74%5∀?Ε(%>∋Φ%#?∀( ∀∃( 5∋?( #∀7Α#?∋?( 3Λ7∃47∋?( Φ( 2Α∆
+%∃∋?(>∋#(+∀&4∋(&∀(Α∃%(+∀Η∋#%(Φ(%73Α%54,%74∗∃Ε(
+∀Η∋#%+4∀∃3∋(∀∃(∀5(%77∀?∋(ΙΑ∀(34∀∃∀(5%(>∋Β5%74∗∃(
%(5∋?(?∀#Γ474∋?(ΗΑ&474%5∀?Ε(∀5(.∋#3%5∀74+4∀∃3∋(&∀(5%(
>#∀Γ∀∃74∗∃(&∀5(&∀543∋(Φ(5%(%3∀∃74∗∃(%(5%?(Γ≅734+%?(
Φ(+∀Η∋#%(∀∃(5%?(7∋∃&474∋∃∀?(ΙΑ∀(34∀∃∀∃(ΙΑ∀(Γ4Γ4#(
5%?(>∀#?∋∃%?(∀∃(?43Α%74∗∃(&∀(&∀3∀∃74∗∃(∋(7∋∃&∀∆
∃%&%?(∀∃(5∋?(7∀∃3#∋?(>∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋?6(
95(>5%∃(&∀(ΗΑ?3474%(&∀?%##∋55%&∋(&Α#%∃3∀( 5∋?(&∋?(
>∀#4∋&∋?(&∀5(/∋Β4∀#∃∋( &∀( τ5Γ%#∋( ;#4Β∀( α−ΨΨ−∆
Υ53∀#∃%34Γ%?(>%#%(?Α>∀#%#(∀5(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(7%#7∀5%#4∋(∀∃(Κ∋5∋+Β4%(7∋∃(∀∃.∋ΙΑ∀(∀∃(&∀#∀72∋?(2Α+%∃∋?
Criterio Jurídico Garantista. (Jul.-Dic. de 2015). Vol. 8, n.o 13, 176-189.
issn
: 2145-3381. Bogotá: Universidad Autónoma de Colombia.
185
−ΨΝΨβ(?∀(∀∃.∋7∗(∀∃(3#%3%#(&∀(4/Α%5(.∋#+%(5%(>#∋∆
Β5∀+Χ347%( &∀5( +%∃∀Η∋( #%74∋∃%5( &∀( 5∋?( #∀7Α#?∋?Ε(
∀∃( +∀Η∋#%#( 5∋?( +∀7%∃4?+∋?( &∀( %>∋Φ∋( ΗΑ&474%5(
α3Λ7∃47∋( Φ( 2Α+%∃∋β( Φ( ∀5( %77∀?∋( %( 5∋?( ?∀#Γ474∋?(
ΗΑ&474%5∀?Ε( +%#7%&∋?( >∋#( Α∃%( %53%( 7∋∃/∀?34∗∃Ε(
4∃∋>∀#%34Γ4&%&(∀(4∃∀.474∀∃74%6(=∋(∋Β?3%∃3∀Ε(%5(?∀#(
Α∃%(>∋5≅347%( ∀+4∃∀∃3∀+∀∃3∀(#∀>#∀?4Γ%(∀∃(+%3∀∆
#4%(7#4+4∃%5Ε(5%?(?∋5Α74∋∃∀?(&%&%?(?∀(∀∃.∋7%#∋∃(
∀∃(∀?∀(∀?>∀73#∋6
!4∃%5+∀∃3∀Ε( ∀∃( ∀5( >#4+∀#( /∋Β4∀#∃∋( :%∃3∋?(
α−ΨΝΨ∆−ΨΝ[β(∀5(>5%∃( &∀(ΗΑ?3474%(?∀(∀∃7%+4∃∗(2%∆
74%(5%(+∋&∀#∃4,%74∗∃Ε(Α3454,%∃&∋(7∋+∋(>#4∃74>%5(
2∀##%+4∀∃3%(∀5( Α?∋(&∀(5%?( 3∀7∃∋5∋/≅%?Ε(&∀Β4&∋(%(
5%( ∀Γ4&∀∃3∀( ∃∀7∀?4&%&( &∀( %>∋Φ%#( 5%?( 4∃Γ∀?34/%∆
74∋∃∀?(Φ(7%&%(Α∃%(&∀(5%?(∀3%>%?(&∀( 5∋?(>#∋7∀?∋?(
ΗΑ&474%5∀?(∀∃(5%?(2∀##%+4∀∃3%?(%>∋#3%&%?(>∋#(5%?(
3∀7∃∋5∋/≅%?(&∀(5%(4∃.∋#+%74∗∃(Φ(5%(7∋+Α∃47%74∗∃(
α
#3∃
β6
:∀( >Α∀&∀( 7∋∃75 Α4#( ΙΑ∀( 5∋?( &4Γ∀#?∋? ( >5%∃∀?( &∀(
ΗΑ?3474%( ?∀( ∀∃+%#7%#∋∃(∀∃(Α∃( &4?7Α#?∋(∀.474∀∃∆
34?3%Ε(∀5(+%∃∀Η∋(#%74∋∃%5(&∀(5∋?(#∀7Α#?∋?Ε(5%(Βλ?∆
ΙΑ∀&%( >∀#+%∃∀∃3∀( &∀( +∀7%∃4?+∋?( &∀( %>∋Φ∋(
3Λ7∃47∋(Φ(2Α+%∃∋Ε(Φ(∀5(+∀Η∋#%+4∀∃3∋(&∀5(%77∀?∋(
%(5∋?(?∀#Γ474∋?(ΗΑ&474%5∀?Ε(5∋(ΙΑ∀(?4∃(&Α&%(∃∋(2%(
?4&∋( >∋?4Β5∀( &∀Β4&∋( %( ΙΑ∀( >#4+%∃(+Χ?( 4∃3∀#∀∆
?∀?(>∋5≅347∋?Ε(7∋ΦΑ∃3Α#%5∀?(∋(&∀(7∋##Α>74∗∃(ΙΑ∀(
4+>4&∀∃(?Α(+%3∀#4%54,%74∗∃(#∀%5( ΦΕ(>∋#(∀∃&∀Ε(∀∃(
Α∃%(ΗΑ?3474%(∃%&%(%7∋#&∀(7∋∃(5%?(∀ϑ4/∀∃74%?(&∀(
∀?3∀(∃Α∀Γ∋(+45∀∃4∋(α∃4?3∀#4∋(&∀(οΑ?3474%(Φ(&∀5(
η∀#∀72∋Ε(−ΨΝ[β6
!#∀∃3∀(%(∀?3∋?(>5%∃∀?(Φ(5%(>#∋Β5∀+Χ347%(%∃%54,%∆
&%Ε(7∋∃Γ4∀∃∀(+4#%#(%(7∋∃34∃Α%74∗∃(5%?(%53∀#∃%34∆
Γ%?(∀∃(+%3∀#4%(&∀(>∋5≅347%(7%#7∀5%#4%Ε(?4∃(∋5Γ4&%#(
∀5( ∃.∋#+∀( !4∃%5( >#∀?∀∃3%&∋( >∋#( 5%( Κ∋+4?4∗∃(
Υ?∀?∋#%(&∀(Τ∋5≅347%(Κ#4+4∃%5(α−ΨΝ−βΕ(4+>Α5?%&∋(
&Α#%∃3∀(∀5(/∋Β4∀#∃∋(:%∃3∋?Ε(∀∃(∀5(7Α%5(?∀(∀?3%Β5∀∆
74∀#∋∃(Α∃%( ?∀#4∀( &∀( #∀7∋+∀∃&%74∋∃∀?Ε(∀∃3#∀(5%?(
7Α%5∀?(?∀(&∀?3%7%∃Ξ(
π( +>5∀+∀∃3%74∗∃( &∀( Α∃( χΚ∀#34.47%&∋( &∀( &4?∆
>∋∃4Β454&%&(7%#7∀5%#4%δ(ΙΑ∀(5∀(>∀#+43%(%5(ΗΑ∀,(
7∋∃∋7∀#(5%(&4?>∋?474∗∃(&∀(7Α>∋?(7%#7∀5%#4∋?6
(π( η∀?>∀∃%54,%74∗∃( &∀5( %Β∋#3∋Ξ( ∀?3∀( %?>∀73∋( ?∀(
∀∃.∋7%(>#4∃74>%5+∀∃3∀( 2%74%( 5∋?(&∀#∀72∋?(&∀(
5%?(+ΑΗ∀#∀?Ε(∀?>∀7≅.47%+∀∃3∀(%(5%?(ΙΑ∀(?∋∃(Γ≅7∆
34+%?(&∀(Γ4∋5∀∃74%(?∀ϑΑ%56(
(π( 8∀?7%3∀( &∀5( &∀54 3∋( >∋5≅347∋Ξ( %5( ?Α>#4+4#?∀( ∀5(
&∀543∋( >∋5≅347∋( &Α#%∃3∀( 5%( %&+4∃4?3#%74∗∃(
;#4Β∀Ε(5%?(7Χ#7∀5∀?(( Β%Η∋(5%( >∋5≅347%(&∀(:∀/Α∆
#4&%&( η∀+∋7#Χ347%Ε( 3ΑΓ4∀#∋ ∃( Α∃( 4∃7#∀+∀∃∆
3∋(?4/∃4.47%34Γ∋Ε(ΙΑ∀(∃∋( 5∋( 2ΑΒ4∀#%(?4&∋(?4(?∀(
+%∃34∀∃∀( ∀?3%( .4/Α#%( ΗΑ#≅&47%( Φ( ∃∋( 5%( &∀(3∀∆
##∋#4?3%κ(∀?(&∀74#Ε(ΙΑ∀(∃∋(?∀(%?Α+4∗(5%(∃∋74∗∃(
&∀( 7∋∃.5473∋( %#+%&∋Ε( ?4∃∋( 5%( &∀( 3∀# #∋#4?+∋6(
Σ%(>#4+∀#%(4+>547%(Α∃(3#%3%+4∀∃3∋(>∋5≅347∋(%(
5%?(>∀#?∋∃%?(7%>3Α#%&%?Ε(∀∃( 3%∃3∋(ΙΑ∀(5%( ?∀∆
/Α∃&%(55∀Γ∗(%(2%7∀#(+Χ?(/#%Γ∋?%(5%(?43Α%74∗∃(
&∀(5%?(7Χ#7∀5∀?6
π( 9Γ43%#(>∋5≅347%?(&∀(χ>∋>Α54?+∋(>Α∃434Γ∋δΕ(7∋∃(
5%?(7Α%5∀?( ∀5(9?3%&∋( ?∀(2%( 7∀∃3#%&∋(∀∃(5%(4∃∆
3∀#Γ∀∃74∗∃( >∀∃%5( >%#%( %?Α+4#( Α∃%( ?∀#4∀( &∀(
7∋∃&Α73%?(&∀(5%(>∋Β5%74∗∃6(
π( Υ+>54%74∗∃(&∀5(.Α∀#∋(&∀(5∋?(+4543%#∀?Ξ(>%#%(5%(
Κ∋+4?4∗∃(Υ?∀?∋#%(∀?3%(>∋5≅347%(>Α∀&∀(7∋∃&Α∆
74#(4∃∀Γ43%Β5∀+∀∃3∀(%(Α∃%(+%Φ∋#(Γ4∋5%74∗∃(&∀(
5∋?(&∀#∀72∋?(2Α+%∃∋?Ε(7∋∃(∀5(%/#%Γ%∃3∀(&∀(4#(
%7∋+>%ν%&%(&∀(Α∃%(+%Φ∋#(4+>Α∃4&%&6
(π( ∃75Α?4∗∃( &∀( 5%?( ∀+>#∀?%?( 7∋+∋( /∀∃∀# %&∋∆
#%?(&∀(%73∋?(&∀(7∋##Α>74∗∃Ξ(?∀(>#∋>∋∃∀(∀∃(∀?∀(
?∀∃34&∋(ΙΑ∀(%5(∃∋(>∋&∀#(+∀3∀#5%?(∀∃(5%(7Χ#7∀5Ε(
Criterio Jurídico Garantista. (Jul.-Dic. de 2015). Vol. 8, n.o 13, 176-189.
issn
: 2145-3381. Bogotá: Universidad Autónoma de Colombia.
)∗+,−,&.∋/01∗2∋).+∗+.
186
?∀(/∀∃∀#∀(7∋+∋(>#4∃74>%5(%.∀73%74∗∃(?Α(+Α∀#∆
3∀(7∋#>∋#%34Γ%6
(π( +>∋?4Β454&%&( &∀( 7∋∃&∀∃%( %( 3∋&∋?( 5∋?( %Α3∋∆
#∀?(&∀(7#≅+∀∃∀?( &∀( 5∀?%( 2Α+%∃4&%&Ξ( >%#%( 5%(
Κ∋+4?4∗∃(Υ?∀?∋#%(#∀?Α53%(4∃?∋?3∀∃4Β5∀(ΙΑ∀(?∀(
ΗΑ,/Α∀∃(%(3∋&∋?(5∋?(>∀#>∀3#%&∋#∀?(&∀(7#≅+∀∆
∃∀?(&∀(5∀?%(2Α+%∃4&%&Ε(&%&∋(ΙΑ∀(5%(+%/∃43Α&(
&∀(3%5∀?( 7#≅+∀∃∀?(Φ(&∀5( ∃λ+∀#∋(&∀(>∀#?∋∃%?(
ΙΑ∀( >%#3474>%#∋∃( 2%7∀( 4+∆
>∋?4Β5∀(ΙΑ∀(?∀(>Α∀&%(%>547%#(
∀?3%(#∀/5%6
(π( 8∀∋#4∀∃3%74∗∃( &∀( 5%( /Α∀∆
##%( 7∋∃3#%( 5%( >#∋&Α774∗∃(
Φ( 3#Χ.47∋( &∀( 7∋7%≅∃%Ξ( ∀?3%(
#∀∋#4∀∃3%74∗∃( ∀?3Χ( #∀5%74∋∆
∃%&%( 7∋∃( 5∋?( +∀7%∃4?+∋?(
&∀( %?>∀#?4∗∃( %Λ#∀%( Φ( ∀##%∆
&47%74∗∃( +%∃Α%5Ε( ΙΑ∀( ?∋∃(
&∀+%?4%&∋( 7∋?3∋?∋?( Φ( ∃∋(
#∀>∋#3%∃(5∋?(#∀?Α53%&∋?(ΙΑ∀(
?∀(∀?>∀#%∃6
η∀(∋3#∋(5%&∋Ε(?∋Β#∀(∀5(3∀+%(&∀(
5%( >∋5≅347%( 7%#7∀5%#4%( ∀?( ΓΧ54∆
&∋(∀5(%>∋#3∀(&∀(Κ∋Φ5∀( α−ΨΨ−βΕ(
ΙΑ4∀∃( ∀5%Β∋#%( Α∃%( >#∋>Α∀?3%(
>%#%( ΙΑ∀( 5%( %&+4∃4?3#%74∗∃(
&∀(∀?3∋?( 7∀∃3#∋?(?∀%(7∋2∀#∀∃3∀( 7∋∃(5%?( %73Α%5∀?(
∀ϑ4/∀∃74%?( Φ( >#4∃74>4∋?( ∀?3%Β5∀74&∋?( >∋#( 5%( 7∋∆
+Α∃4&%&(4∃3∀#∃%74∋∃%5(α
.,!
7∋
.∗−
β(Φ(∀5(#Λ/4+∀∃(
>∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋(∀∃(Κ∋5∋+Β4%6(
;∃∋(&∀( ∀?3∋?( %?>∀73∋?( %( 3∀∃∀#( ∀∃( 7Α∀∃3%( ∀?( ∀5(
>∀#?∋∃%5(>∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋Ε(∀5(7Α%5( &∀Β∀(%73Α%#( Β%Η∋(
Α∃∋?(7#43∀#4∋?(Λ347∋?(+ΑΦ(.Α∀#3∀?(Φ(Β4∀∃(%?4+45%∆
&∋?Ε(Φ%(ΙΑ∀(?∀(∀?3Χ(2%Β5%∃&∋(&∀5(∀Η∀#7474∋(>∀#+%∆
∃∀∃3∀(&∀(%Α3∋#4&%&(?∋Β#∀(Α∃(>∀#?∋∃%5(ΙΑ∀(?∀(∀∃∆
7Α∀∃3#%(∀∃(7∋∃&474∋∃∀?(54+43%&%?(&∀(+∋Γ454&%&(Φ(
54Β∀#3%&6
ς%Η∋(∀?3∀(4+>∀#%34Γ∋(Λ347∋Ε(∀5(%Α3∋#( >5%∃3∀%(ΙΑ∀(
5∋?( .Α∃74∋∃%#4∋?( >∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋?( ?∀( &∀Β∀∃( /Α4%#(
∀∃(%?>∀73∋?(3%5∀?(7∋+∋Ξ(3#%3∋(&∀7∀∃3∀(%(5∋?(#∀75Α∆
?∋?(α7∋∃(&4/∃4&%&( Φ( ΗΑ?3474%βκ( /%#%∃34,%#( ?Α( ?∀∆
/Α#4&%&(∀∃(3∋&∋( +∋+∀∃3∋κ(∀Γ43%#(5%(.Α/%(&∀(5∋?(
#∀75Α?∋?(+Χ?(>∀54/#∋?∋?κ(7Α4&%#(ΙΑ∀(∀5(∋#&∀∃(Φ(∀5(
7∋∃3#∋5( &∀( 5%?( >#4?4∋∃∀?(
?∀( +%∃3∀∃/%Ε( Φ( >#∋+∋∆
Γ∀#( Φ( >∀#+434#( ∀5( %>#∋∆
Γ∀72%+4∀∃3∋(>∋?434Γ∋(&∀5(
34∀+>∋(>∋#( >%#3∀( &∀( 5∋?(
#∀75Α?∋?6(9∃( ∀?∀( ?∀∃34&∋(
.∋#+Α5%( 5%?( ?4/Α4∀∃3∀?(
?Α/∀#∀∃74%?Ξ(
π(Σ∋?(4∃3∀#∃∋?(34∀∃∀(&∀∆
#∀72∋(%(7∋∃∋7∀#(&∀(%∃3∀∆
+%∃∋(%( ΙΑΛ( ?∀( ∀ϑ>∋∃∀∃(
7∋∃( ∀5( >#∋7∀&4+4∀∃3∋( Φ(
5%( >∀#?∋∃%( ΙΑ∀( 5∋?( &∀∆
∃Α∃74∗6
π(Μ∋&∋?(5∋?(7%?∋?( &∀Β∀∃(
?∀#(3#%3%&∋?(>∋#( Α∃%(%Α∆
3∋#4&%&( 7∋+>∀3∀∃3∀( Φ(
7∋∃.∋#+∀( %( Α∃∋?( 54∃∀%∆
+4∀∃3∋?(>#∀Γ4%+∀∃3∀(.4Η%&∋?6(
(π( 9?(4+>∋#3%∃3∀( ΙΑ∀( ∀5(%7Α?%&∋(∀?3Λ(>#∀?∀∃3∀(
+4∀∃3#%?(&Α#∀(∀5(>#∋7∀&4+4∀∃3∋(&4?74>54∃%#4∋6(
(π( 9∃( 7%?∋( &∀( ?∀#( 2%55%&∋( 7Α5>%Β5∀Ε( ∀5( 4∃3∀#∃∋(
&∀Β∀(&4?>∋∃∀#( &∀(Α∃(#∀7Α#?∋( &∀( %>∀5%74∗∃(∀5(
7Α%5(&∀Β∀(?∀#(.%55%&∋(>∋#(Α∃%(%Α3∋#4&%&(?Α>∀∆
#4∋#6(
(π( η∀Β∀∃(∀ϑ4?34#(+∀7%∃4?+∋?(&∀(?%∃74∋∃∀?(Χ/4∆
5∀?(>%#%(5%?( 4∃.#%774∋∃∀?( &4?74>54∃%#4%?( 5∀Γ∀?Ε(
γ3#%(7∋?%(4+>∋#3%∃3∀(
ΙΑ∀(#∀7%57%(5%(Κ∋#3∀(
Κ∋∃?343Α74∋∃%5(?∋∃(5%?(
/#%Γ∀?(∋+4?4∋∃∀?(∀∃(
ΙΑ∀(∀?3Χ∃(4∃7Α##4∀∃&∋(
5%?(&4Γ∀#?%?(%Α3∋#4&%&∀?(
>λΒ547%?(∀∃7%#/%&%?(&∀(5%(
>#∋3∀774∗∃(&∀(5∋?(&∀#∀72∋?(
.Α∃&%+∀∃3%5∀?(&∀(5∋?(
4∃3∀#∃∋?Ε(&∀(%2≅(ΙΑ∀(∀ϑ4/∀Ε(
+%∃&%Ε(∋#&∀∃%Ε(ΙΑ∀(?∀(
#∀+∀&4∀∃(5%?(?43Α%74∋∃∀?(
>%#%(?Α>∀#%#(3%5(∀?3%&∋(&∀((
4∃7∋∃?343Α74∋∃%54&%&6
Υ53∀#∃%34Γ%?(>%#%(?Α>∀#%#(∀5(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(7%#7∀5%#4∋(∀∃(Κ∋5∋+Β4%(7∋∃(∀∃.∋ΙΑ∀(∀∃(&∀#∀72∋?(2Α+%∃∋?
Criterio Jurídico Garantista. (Jul.-Dic. de 2015). Vol. 8, n.o 13, 176-189.
issn
: 2145-3381. Bogotá: Universidad Autónoma de Colombia.
187
?4∃( ΙΑ∀( ∀55∋( 4+>54ΙΑ∀( ∃∀7∀?%#4%+∀∃3∀( 3∀∃∀#(
ΙΑ∀(#∀7Α##4#(%(Α∃(>#∋7∀&4+4∀∃3∋(5∀/%56(
:∀( >Α∀&∀( &∀74#Ε(.4∃%5+∀∃3∀Ε( ΙΑ∀( .#∀∃3∀( %5( 2%74∆
∃%+4∀∃3∋( Φ( >∀#+%∃∀∃3∀( Γ4∋5%74∗∃( &∀( 5∋?(
&&
%∋
((
6
Ε(∀?(∀Γ4&∀∃3∀(5%(∃∀7∀?4&%&(&∀(7∋##∀734Γ∋?(ΙΑ∀(
>∀#+43%∃(2%7∀#(Α∃%(%&∀7Α%74∗∃(&∀(5%(5∀/4?5%74∗∃(
∃%74∋∃%5(7∋∃.∋#+∀(%(5∋?(>%#Χ+∀3#∋?(4∃3∀#∃%74∋∆
∃%5∀?(∀∃(∀?3%(+%3∀#4%Ε(?4∀∃&∋(>∋?4Β5∀(>5%∃3∀%#(5%?(
?4/Α4∀∃3∀?(>#∋>Α∀?3%?Ξ(
π( Κ#∀%74∗∃(&∀( Α∃%(5∀Φ( &∀(%53∀#∃%34Γ4&%&(>∀∃%5Ε(
Β%?%&%(∀∃(Α∃(3#%3%+4∀∃3∋(#%74∋∃%5(Φ(2Α+%∃4∆
,%&∋#Ε(>∀#∋( 3∀∃4∀∃&∋( ∀∃( 7Α∀∃3%( 5∋?( >∋?4Β5∀?(
∀.∀73∋?(2%74%(5%?(Γ≅734+%?6(
(π( Κ#∀%74∗∃( &∀( >#∋Φ∀73∋?( >#∋&Α734Γ∋?( ∋#4∀∃3%∆
&∋?( 2%74%( 5%( .∋#+%74∗∃( &∀( 7∋+>∀3∀∃74%?( 5%∆
Β∋#%5∀?Ε(>%#%( ΙΑ∀( 5%( #∀?∋74%54,%74∗∃( 3∀∃/%(5%(
.Α∃74∗∃(ΙΑ∀(2%?3%(%2∋#%(∃∋(2%(?4&∋(>∋?4Β5∀6(
(π( 9?3%Β5∀7∀#( 7%+Β4∋?( ∀∃( 5%( >∋5≅347%( 7#4+4∃%5Ε(
∀∃3#∀(∋3#∋?Ε(∀∃( 5%(#∀?>Α∀?3%( &∀5(9?3%&∋( .#∀∃∆
3∀(%(5∋?(45≅743∋?(>∀∃%5∀?Ε(>%#%(5∋(7Α%5(?∀(&∀Β∀∃(
>#∋+∋Γ∀#(+∀7%∃4?+∋?( %53∀# ∃%34Γ∋?(7∋+∋( 5%(
7∋∃7454%74∗∃Ε(+∀&4%74∗∃(Φ(#∀>%#%74∗∃Ε(∀?(&∀74#Ε(
&∀∃3#∋(&∀5(+%#7∋( &∀( 5%( ΗΑ?3474%( 3#%∃?474∋∃%5Ε(
Φ%(ΙΑ∀( ?∀( &∀Β∀∃( 3∀∃∀#( ∀∃(7Α∀∃3%(5∋?(∀.∀73∋?(
?∋Β#∀(5%?(Γ≅734+%?6(
π( η∀?%##∋55%#(Α∃%(>∋5≅347%(>λΒ547%( ∋#4∀∃3%&%( %(
5%(7#∀%74∗∃( &∀( >#4∃74>4∋?(Φ(ΒΑ∀∃%?( >#Χ7347%?Ε(
Α∃%(&∀(∀55%?(5%(&∀.4∃474∗∃(&∀(5%?(>5%,%?(&4?>∋∆
∃4Β5∀?(∀∃(7%&%(Α∃∋( &∀(5∋?(7∀∃3#∋?( 7%#7∀5%#4∋?(
α4∃.∋#+%74∗∃(>λΒ547%(Φ(%77∀?4Β5∀β6
(π( 8∀.∋#+%#(∀5(Κ∗&4/∋(Τ∀∃%5(>∋#(7Α%∃3∋(∀5(∀ϑ7∀∆
?4Γ∋(3#%3%+4∀∃3∋(>Α∃434Γ∋(%( 5%?(7∋∃&Α73%?( &∀(
5∋?(74Α&%&%∃∋?( 2%(&∀7%∃3%&∋(∀∃( Α∃%(>∋5≅347%(
7#4+4∃%5(∃∀3%+∀∃3∀(#∀>#∀?4Γ%Ε(5∋(ΙΑ∀(4+>547%(
∃∀7∀?%#4%+∀∃3∀( Α∃( 4∃7#∀+∀∃3∋( &∀( 5%( >∋Β5%∆
74∗∃( 7%#7∀5%#4%Ε( %?>∀73∋( ΙΑ∀( ∃∋( .Α∀( #∀?Α∀53∋(
7∋∃(5%?(+∀&4&%?(>Α∃434Γ%?6
(
Conclusiones
Σ%?(%53∀#∃%34Γ%?( ΙΑ∀(?∀( >5%∃3∀%∃(>%#%(5%(#∀&Α7∆
74∗∃(&∀5(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(7%#7∀5%#4∋(Γ%∃(∀∃(&∋?(?∀∃∆
34&∋?Ξ(Α∃∋(+%7#∋Ε(3∀∃&4∀∃3∀(%(2%7∀#(∀.∀734Γ∋?(5∋?(
&∀#∀72∋?(.Α∃&%+∀∃3%5∀?(&∀(5%(>∋Β5%74∗∃(#∀75Α?%(
&∀5(>%≅?Ε(%(3#%ΓΛ?(&∀(Α∃%(5∀/4?5%74∗∃(ΙΑ∀(7∋∃3∀+∆
>5∀(∀5( 3#%3%+4∀∃3∋( 3#4>5∀(&∀(5%( >∋5≅347%( 7#4+4∃%5(
α>#∀Γ∀∃74∗∃Ε(#∀>#∀?4∗∃Ε(#∀?∋74%54,%74∗∃βκ(Α∃∋(+4∆
7#∋Ε(#∀.∀#4&∋( %( 5∋?( 7∀∃3#∋?( >∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋?( 7∋+∋(
3%5∀?Ε( ∀∃( 5%?( ΙΑ∀( ?∀( .4Η∀∃( >%#Χ+∀3#∋?( 75%#∋?( &∀(
3#%3%+4∀∃3∋(%(5∋?(>#4Γ%&∋?(&∀(5%(54Β∀#3%&6
9∃(#∀5%74∗∃(7∋∃(5%(>∋5≅347%(7%#7∀5%#4%(?∀(&∀Β∀∃(
3∀∃∀#(∀∃(7Α∀∃3%(5%?(#∀7∋+∀∃&%74∋∃∀?(&%&%?(>∋#(
5%(Κ∋+4?4∗∃(Υ?∀?∋#%(&∀(Τ∋5≅347%(Κ#4+4∃%5(∀∃(5∋?(
?4/Α4∀∃3∀?(%?>∀73∋?Ε(ΙΑ∀(?4∃(&Α&%(4∃.5ΑΦ∀∃(∀∃( 5%(
#∀&Α774∗∃(&∀5(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋( 7%#7∀5%#4∋Ξ(7#∀%74∗∃(
&∀( Α∃( 7∀#34.47%&∋( &∀( &4?>∋∃4Β454&%&( 7%#7∀5%#4%(
ΙΑ∀(5∀(>∀#+43%(%5(ΗΑ∀,(&∀3∀#+4∃%#(∀5(?434∋(&∀(#∀∆
75Α?4∗∃Ε(&∀?>∀∃%54,%74∗∃( &∀5( %Β∋#3∋Ε( #∀?7%3∀(&∀5(
&∀543∋(>∋5≅347∋Ε(%7%Β%#(7∋∃(∀5(>∋>Α54?+∋(>Α∃434Γ∋Ε(
#∀72%,∋(%(5%( %+>54%74∗∃(&∀5(.Α∀#∋(+4543%#Ε(4∃75Α∆
?4∗∃(&∀(5%?(∀+>#∀?%?(7∋+∋(/∀∃∀#%&∋#%?(&∀(%73∋?(
&∀(7∋##Α>74∗∃(ΙΑ∀(>∀#+43%(3%+Β4Λ∃(5%(%>547%74∗∃(
&∀(Α∃%( ?%∃74∗∃Ε(4+>∋?4Β454&%&(&∀( 7∋∃&∀∃%(%( 3∋∆
&∋?(5∋?(%Α3∋#∀?(&∀(7#≅+∀∃∀?(&∀(5∀?%(2Α+%∃4&%&(Φ(
#∀∋#4∀∃3%74∗∃(&∀(5%(>∋5≅347%(%∃34∋/%?6(
!4∃%5+∀∃3∀Ε(∀?(75%#∋(ΙΑ∀(5%(>∋5≅347%(7#4+4∃%5(7∋∆
5∋+Β4%∃%(∀∃(+%3∀#4%(&∀(3#%3%+4∀∃3∋(&∀(5∋?(7∀∃∆
3#∋?(7%#7∀5%#4∋?( &∀Β∀( ∀∃.∋7%#?∀(2%74%(5%( ∀?3#Α7∆
3Α#%74∗∃( &∀( .∋#+%?( %53∀#∃%34Γ%?( &∀( 5%( >∀∃%Ε( ∀∃(
3%∃3∋(?∀(&∀Β∀∃(ΒΑ?7%#(+∀7%∃4?+∋?(7∋+∋(5%(7∋∃∆
Criterio Jurídico Garantista. (Jul.-Dic. de 2015). Vol. 8, n.o 13, 176-189.
issn
: 2145-3381. Bogotá: Universidad Autónoma de Colombia.
)∗+,−,&.∋/01∗2∋).+∗+.
188
7454%74∗∃Ε(+∀&4%74∗∃(Φ(#∀>%#%74∗∃(∀∃(∀5(+%#7∋(&∀(
5%(ΗΑ?3474%(3#%∃?474∋∃%5Ε(+Χϑ4+∀(7Α%∃&∋(?∀(∀?3Χ∃(
55∀Γ%∃&∋(%(7%Β∋(>#∋7∀?∋?(∋#4∀∃3%&∋?(%(5%(>%,Ε(5∋(
ΙΑ∀(4+>547%#Χ(∃∀7∀?%#4%+∀∃3∀( 7#∀%#(Α∃∋?(+∀7%∆
∃4?+∋?(∀.474∀∃3∀?(&∀(Γ∀#&%&Ε(ΗΑ?3474%Ε(#∀>%#%74∗∃(
Φ(∃∋(#∀>∀3474∗∃6(
Referencias
Υ7∋?3%Ε(η6(αΝΘΘ0β6( :#0∃%5.∋ #/∃%6∀.4∋+%∋ ∃∀.∃.5#%/3
∃&∋ 7∀&6∀%0#8&∋ 7%/#∃%/,#.∀#&9∋ :%;4%
/&∋ .∋ 4.∋ ,&/0∃∀),,#=/∋ +%∋ )/∋ 5&+%4&∋ +%∋ .∃%/,#=/∋
.∋ #/∃%∀/&09( ς∋/∋3ΧΞ(
3,∀∗∃
6( γΒ3∀∃4&∋( &∀( 4∃∆
>∀7Ξ( 233>ΞΖΖ]]]64∃>∀76/∋Γ67∋Ζ>∋#3%5Ζ>%/∀Ζ
>∋#3%5Ζ ∃>∀7Ζ ∃? 343Α7 4∋ ∃Ζ9?3Α& 4∋−Ψ
Τ∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋?ΖΝ6−6>&.
Υ#%∃/∋Ε(Σ6( α−ΨΝΠβ6( >4∋ ?.,#/.5#%/∃&∋,.∀,%4.∀#&∋ %/∋
!&4&5≅#.6( γΒ3∀∃4&∋( &∀( >∋54347%7∋5∋+Β4%∆
∃%−ΨΝΠΞ( 233>ΞΖΖ>∋54347%7∋5∋+Β4%∃%−ΨΝΠ6
]∋# &> #∀??67∋+ Ζ−ΨΝΠ ΖΨΝ[Ζ ∀5∆2% 74 ∃%
+4∀∃3∋∆7%#7∀5%#4∋∆∀∃∆7∋5∋+Β4%Ζυ6
Υ#4%?Ε(!6(α−ΨΝΠβ6(Α.,#/.5#%/∃&∋,.∀,%4.∀#&1∋7∀&≅4%5.∋
4%6#04.∃#8&∋ &∋ +%∋ #/;∀.%0∃∀),∃)∀.6(ς∋/∋3ΧΞ( ;∃4∆
Γ∀#?4&%&(
ς∋#Η%Ε(96( α−ΨΨΠ%β6(!)∀0&∋+%∋7&4∗∃#,.∋,∀#5#/.46(Ω%∆
5∀∃74%Ξ(Μ4#%∃3(Σ∋(ς5%∃726
ς∋#Η%Ε(96(α−ΨΨΠΒβ6(:∋Β#∀(∀5( 7∋∃7∀>3∋(&∀( >∋5≅347%(
7#4+4∃%56(;∃%(%>#∋ϑ4+%74∗∃(%(?Α(?4/∃4.47%&∋(
&∀?&∀(5%(∋Β#%(&∀(Κ5%Α?(8∋ϑ4∃6(Β/).∀#&∋+%∋+%3
∀%,?&∋7%/.4∋Χ∋,#%/,#.0∋7%/.4%01∋
!∀#
Ε(ΝΝΠ∆ΝΟΨ6((
Κ∀#&%?Ε(86(α−ΨΨ[β6(∆%5&,∀.,#.∋Χ∋+%∀%,?&0∋?)5./&06(
∃?343Α3∋(∃3∀#%+∀#47%∃∋( &∀( η∀#∀∆
72∋?(_Α+%∃∋?6(
Κ∋+4?4∗∃(Υ?∀?∋#%( &∀(Τ∋5≅347%(Κ#4+4∃%56(α−ΨΝ−β6(
Ε/;&∀5%∋ ;#/.49∋ ∆#.6/=0∃#,&∋ Χ∋ 7∀&7)%0∃.∋ +%∋ 4#3
/%.5#%/∃&0∋ +%∋ 7&4∗∃#,.∋ ,∀#5#/.4∋ 7.∀.∋ %4∋ >03
∃.+&∋ ,&4&5≅#./&9∋ ( γΒ3∀∃4&∋( &∀( +4∃ΗΑ?3474%Ξ(
233>?ΞΖΖ]]]6+4∃ΗΑ?3474%6/∋Γ67∋ΖΤ∋#3%5?ΖΨΖ
3,).µ−Ψ∀.83µ−Ψ∃+313,−89)3,−8:;,.6
>&.6(
Σ∀Φ(0Ο( &∀(ΝΘΘΠ6(Τ∋#(5%(7Α%5( ?∀( ∀ϑ>4&∀(∀5(Κ∗&4∆
/∋(Τ∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋(Φ(Κ%#7∀5%#4∋6(Υ/∋?3∋(ΝΘ(&∀(
ΝΘΘΠ6(ηγ6(=ϖ([ΨΘΘΘ6
Κ∋∃?∀Η∋(=%74∋∃%5(&∀( Τ∋5≅347%( 97∋∃∗+47%(Φ(:∋∆
74%56(α−ΨΨΘβ6(>0∃∀.∃%6#.∋7.∀.∋4.∋%+%∋4.∋
&;%∀∃.∋ /.,#&/.4∋+%∋ ,)7&0∋ 7%/#∃%/,#.∀#&0∋ Χ∋ ,.∀,%3
4.∀#&0∋Φ∋0%6)#5#%/∃&∋ .∋4&0∋!&/7%0∋ΓΗΙΙ∋+%∋5.∀3
ϑ&∋+%∋ΗΚΚΛ∋Χ∋ΓΛΜΗ∋+%∋5.∀ϑ&∋+%∋ΗΚΚΝ6(ς∋/∋3ΧΞ(
Κ∋∃>∀?6(
Κ∋#3∀( Κ∋∃?343Α74∋∃%5( &∀( Κ∋5∋+Β4%6( :∀∃3∀∃74%(
Μ∆ΝΟΠ( &∀( ΝΘΘΡ( α6Ξ( 9&Α%#&∋( Κ4.Α∀∃3∀?(
_∋.∀#Ε( !&/0#+%∀.∀∋ 4.∋ 7%∀07%,∃#8.∋
5)/+#.4∋%/∋5.∃%∀#.∋ +%∋?.,#/.5#%/∃&∋ ,.∀,%4.∀#&6(
γΒ3∀∃4&∋( &∀( Α+%Φ∋#Ξ( 233>ΞΖΖ]]]6Α+%Φ∋#6
75Ζ+%454∃/Ζ−ΨΝ−ΖΗΑ∃4∋ΖΝΝ∆Ψ0∆−ΨΝ−Ζ#∀Γ4?∆
3%ω&∀#∀72∋ω>∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋Ζ&∀?7%#/%?Ζ#∀Γ4?∆
3%ω&∀#∀72∋ω>∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋6>&.
∃?343Α3∋( =%74∋∃%5( Τ∀∃43∀∃74%#4∋( Φ( Κ%#7∀5%#4∋6(
α−ΨΝ[β6(Ε/;&∀5%∋%0∃.+∗0∃#,&∋.6&0∃&∋ ΗΚΜΛ6(ς∋/∋∆
3ΧΞ(
3,∀∗∃
6(
∃?343Α3∋(8∋?%#4?3%(&∀(Υ774∗∃(:∋74%56(α−ΨΝΝβ6(∆%3
0.∀∀&44&∋+%4∋0#0∃%5.∋7%/#∃%/,#.∀#&∋Χ∋,.∀,%4.∀#&∋,&3
4&5≅#./&∋%/∃∀%∋ΜΟΟΠ∋ Χ∋ΗΚΜΚ1∋ %/∋%4∋5.∀,&∋ +%∋4.0∋
7&4∗∃#,.0∋+%∋ >0∃.+&∋.∋ 7.∀∃#∀∋+%∋ 4.0∋0%/∃%/,#.0∋ +%∋
4.∋ !&∀∃%∋ !&/0∃#∃),#&/.49∋ ς∋/∋3ΧΞ(;∃4Γ∀#?4&%&(
&∀5( 8∋?%#4∋6( γΒ3∀∃4&∋( &∀( Α#∋?%#4∋Ξ( 233>ΞΖΖ
]]]6Α#∋?%#4∋6∀&Α67∋ΖΥ774∋∃∆:∋74%5Ζ&∋7Α∆
+∀∃3∋?Ζη∀?%##∋55∋ω&∀5ω?4?3∀+%ω>∀∃43∀∃∆
74%#4∋6>&.
Α∃434Γ∋( Φ( 7∋∃3#∋5(
7#4+4∃%56(ΚΧ#7∀5∀?Ε(>#4?4∋∃∀?(Φ(>∀∃43∀∃74%#≅%?(
∀∃(Κ∋5∋+Β4%( ∀∃(∀5( ?4/5∋(
434
6(:%8#0∃.∋ !∀#5#3
/.4#+.+Ε(ΟΟαΝβΕ(ΘΘ∆ΝΝ−6
Υ53∀#∃%34Γ%?(>%#%(?Α>∀#%#(∀5(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(7%#7∀5%#4∋(∀∃(Κ∋5∋+Β4%(7∋∃(∀∃.∋ΙΑ∀(∀∃(&∀#∀72∋?(2Α+%∃∋?
Criterio Jurídico Garantista. (Jul.-Dic. de 2015). Vol. 8, n.o 13, 176-189.
issn
: 2145-3381. Bogotá: Universidad Autónoma de Colombia.
189
Θ.7.∋ +%∋ ∀#%06&0∋+%∋ ,&∀∀)7,#=/6(ς∋/∋3ΧΞ(
ΗΑ?3474%6( γΒ3∀∃4&∋( &∀( +4∃ΗΑ?3474%Ξ( 233>ΞΖΖ
]]]6+4∃ΗΑ?3474%6/∋Γ67∋ΖΤ∋#3%5?ΖΨΖη∋7Α∆
+∀∃3∋?µ−ΨΖ%µ−Ψ&∀µ−Ψ#4∀?∆
/∋?µ−Ψ&∀µ−ΨΚ∋##Α>74µΚΠµςΠ∃µ−Ψ−ΨΝ[6
>&.6(
γση∋∃∀55Ε(η6(α−ΨΨ[β6( ∆%∀%,?&∋Ε/∃%∀/.,#&/.4∋ +%∋4&0∋
+%∀%,?&0∋?)5./&09∋ Ρ&∀5.∃#8.1∋Σ)∀#07∀)+%/,#.∋ Χ∋
+&,∃∀#/.∋+%∋ 4&0∋ 0#0∃%5.0∋ )/#8%∀0.4∋%∋ #/∃%∀.5%∀#3
,./&6(ς∋/∋3Χ(η6(Κ6Ξ( γ.474∃%(∀∃(Κ∋5∋+Β4%(&∀5(
Υ53∋( Κ∋+4?4∋∃%&∋( &∀( 5%?( =%74∋∃∀?( ;∃4&%?(
>%#%(5∋?(η∀#∀72∋?(_Α+%∃∋?6
γ#/%∃4,%74∗∃( &∀( 5%?( =%74∋∃∀?( ;∃4&%?6( α−ΨΝΝβ(
ΤΥ)ς∋0&/∋ 4&0∋+%∀%,?&0∋ ?)5./&0Ω()4∃∀Β#%Ε( :Α4∆
,%Ξ(
.,!
6( γΒ3∀∃4&∋( &∀( ∋272#Ξ( 233>ΞΖΖ]]]6
∋272#6∋#/Ζ:ΤΖ??Α∀?ΖΤ%/∀?Ζφ2%3%#∀_Α∆
+%∃84/23?6%?>ϑ6
8∋Β5∀?Ε(γ6(α−ΨΝΝβ6(95(2%74∃%+4∀∃3∋(7%#7∀5%#4∋(Φ(
?Α?(7∋∃?∀7Α∀∃74%?6(:%8#0∃.∋+#6#∃.4∋+%∋4.∋Θ.%03
∃∀∗.∋ %/∋ !#%/,#.0∋ Ξ%/.4%0∋ +%∋ 4.∋ Ψ/#8%∀0#+.+∋+%∋
!&0∃.∋:#,.Ε(ΠΕ([ΨΟ∆[ΠΝ6
8∋ϑ4∃Ε(Κ6(αΝΘΘ−β6(Υ7∀#7%(&∀5(&∀?%##∋55∋(#∀74∀∃3∀(
&∀(5%( >∋5≅347%(7#4+4∃%59∋!).+%∀/&0∋+%∋ Ξ&4∗∃#,.∋
!∀#5#/.4Ε([Ρ6(
ΜΛ55∀,(Υ/Α45∀#%Ε(Υ6(αΝΘΘ0β6(η∀#∀72∋(>∀∃43∀∃74%∆
#4∋(7∋5∋+Β4%∃∋Ξ( Α∃%( %>#∋ϑ4+%74∗∃(&∀?&∀(5%(
∀ϑ>∀#4∀∃74%(∀?>%ν∋5%6(Β/).∀#&∋ +%∋ +%∀%,?&∋ 7%3
/.4∋Χ∋,#%/,#.0∋7%/.4%0Ε(ΛΟα−βΕ(ΟΘΝ∆0−Ο6
Criterio Jurídico Garantista. (Jul.-Dic. de 2015). Vol. 8, n.o 13, 176-189.
issn
: 2145-3381. Bogotá: Universidad Autónoma de Colombia.
)∗+,−,&.∋/01∗2∋).+∗+.

Para continuar leyendo

Solicita tu prueba

VLEX utiliza cookies de inicio de sesión para aportarte una mejor experiencia de navegación. Si haces click en 'Aceptar' o continúas navegando por esta web consideramos que aceptas nuestra política de cookies. ACEPTAR